Free Shipping with $49 purchase + Free Store Pickup. Contiguous US. Exclusions
Macy's Presents: The Edit- A curated mix of fashion and inspiration Check It Out
ADS FROM UNAFFILIATED SITES

Best Waterproof Eyeliner

Create dramatic or understated effects with the best waterproof eyeliner on the market. This eye makeup essential is a must-have for bringing out the best of your natural beauty in a smudge-proof formula that promises to outlast the day, rain or shine.

Laura Geller, Bare Escentuals, and Lancôme are just a few designer names offering eyeliners that perfectly complement your chosen eye shadow while keeping a fresh, solid line despite any tears, perspiration, or wet weather. Women that prefer mineral makeup will appreciate a mineral-infused formula that boosts vitamin E, all in an easy-glide pencil applicator that makes it easy to create the right line thickness, or thinness, you desire. Pencil eyeliners provide rich, creamy colors that stay put all day, and these hues go beyond the traditional black and brown. Shake things up with a deep navy, plum, or smoky moss eyeliner that can bring out specks of eye color you didn’t even know were there.

When shopping around for the best waterproof eyeliner that meets your needs, consider liquid eyeliner. Although the application may take some getting used to, especially for those used to pencil liners, liquid eyeliner is packed with rich pigment that glides on like nothing else, creating a bold, dramatic line. Aside from the standard brush application, some liquid liners have a convenient sponge tip applicator for improved control. This makes application even easier for those transitioning from pencil liners. For a night on the town, choose a formula infused with glittering sparkles.

Another option for lasting wear is gel eyeliner. Designed to be applied using a small angled brush, you can also dip any pencil liner into the gel liner for a more controlled application. One benefit of gel liner is that it is crease-resistant and glides on with little effort, but be sure to seal the jar immediately after using to avoid drying out.

Find the best waterproof eyeliner, plus any complementing eye shadows to create your desired effect, when you shop at Macy’s.

more
  • 32 items in Best Waterproof Eyeliner

    • Filter
    • Sort By
    • All Items (32)
    • Free Pick Up
    • Sort by
    • 2 colors
      Lancôme Monsieur Big Mascara
      $25.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      Lancôme French Riviera Collection- Only $45
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      (896)
    • 2 colors
      Benefit Cosmetics roller lash super curling & lifting mascara
      $24.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 2pc Makeup gift w/ $35 benefit purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (328)
    • Lancôme Definicils Lengthening and Defining Waterproof Mascara
      $27.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      Lancôme French Riviera Collection- Only $45
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      (291)
    • 2 colors
      Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara
      $18.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free skincare duo with $55 Clinique purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (345)
    • Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara
      $25.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      Lancôme French Riviera Collection- Only $45
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      (83)
    • Estée Lauder Sumptuous Extreme Waterproof Lash Multiplying Volume Mascara
      $27.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 3 pc skincare gift with $75 Lauder purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (200)
    • Lancôme Hypnose Drama Instant Full Volume Waterproof Mascara
      $27.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      Lancôme French Riviera Collection- Only $45
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      (196)
    • Estée Lauder Little Black Primer
      $25.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 3 pc skincare gift with $75 Lauder purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (265)
    • 2 colors
    • 3 colors
      MAC False Lashes Black Mascara
      $24.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (130)
    • Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara
      $23.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      FREE makeup packette w/ Too Faced purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (74)
    • 3 colors
      Dior Diorshow Waterproof Mascara Backstage Makeup
      $29.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (100)
    • Estée Lauder Pure Color Envy Lash Waterproof Multi Effects Mascara
      $28.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 3 pc skincare gift with $75 Lauder purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (22)
    • MAC In Extreme Dimension Waterproof Mascara
      $24.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (31)
    • Tarte Lights, Camera, Splashes 4-in-1 Waterproof Mascara
      $23.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 2pc Makeup gift w/ $50 Tarte purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (14)
    • Bobbi Brown No Smudge Mascara, 0.18 oz
      $30.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free makeup gift with $50 Bobbi Brown purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (258)
    • Estée Lauder Little Black Primer, Travel-Size
      $10.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 3 pc skincare gift with $75 Lauder purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (104)
    • NEW! Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof Travel Size Mascara
      $12.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      Lancôme French Riviera Collection- Only $45
      BONUS VALUE: $169
    • Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Waterproof Spectacular Volume & Curl Professional Mascara
      $29.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (38)
    • MAC Haute & Naughty Waterproof Lash
      $24.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (36)
    • Lancôme Hypnose Buildable Volume Waterproof Mascara
      $27.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      Lancôme French Riviera Collection- Only $45
      BONUS VALUE: $169
      (110)
    • Shiseido Full Lash Multi-Dimension Waterproof Mascara, 0.29 oz.
      $27.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (29)
    • Dior Diorshow Iconic Waterproof Mascara
      $29.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (14)
    • Dior Diorshow Pump 'N' Volume Waterproof Mascara
      $29.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (1)
    • Laura Mercier Long Lash Mascara
      $26.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $50 Laura Mercier Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (46)
    • IT Cosmetics Tightline 3-in-1 Black Primer Eyeliner Mascara Waterproof
      $24.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (56)
    • Buxom Cosmetics Buxom Lash Waterproof Mascara
      $20.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (13)
    • Dior Diorshow Black Out Waterproof Mascara
      $29.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (3)
    • Smashbox Full Exposure Waterproof Mascara
      $23.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (60)
    • Benefit Cosmetics roller lash curling & lifting mascara mini
      $12.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 2pc Makeup gift w/ $35 benefit purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (328)
    • 2 colors
      NYX Professional Makeup Doll Eye Mascara
      $9.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (119)
    • INGLOT Volume & Waterproof Mascara
      $16.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (4)
    • Showing All 32 Items