Macy's Presents: The Edit- A curated mix of fashion and inspiration Check It Out
Free Shipping with $75 purchase + Free Store Pickup. Contiguous US. Exclusions
  • Gifts under $25 Shop all gifts by Price, Back to the gift Guide shop all gifts by price back to the gift guide
  • 17 items in

    Makeup Gifts Under $25

    • Filter
    • Sort By
    • All Items (17)
    • Free Pickup
    • Sort by
    • 34 colors
      New Colors
      NEW! MAC Matte Lipstick
      $18.50
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (5349)
    • 2 colors
      Lancôme Monsieur Big Mascara, 0.33 oz
      $25.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (1308)
    • 2 colors
      Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
      $24.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (398)
    • 2 colors
      Clinique High Impact Mascara, 0.28 oz
      $19.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (1790)
    • 16 colors
      Clinique Chubby Stick Moisturizing Lip Colour Balm, 0.1 oz
      $18.50
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (2889)
    • 52 colors
      Urban Decay Vice Lipstick
      $19.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (1582)
    • 20 colors
      Lancôme L'Absolu Gloss, 0.27 oz.
      $25.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (51)
    • 11 colors
      MAC Retro Matte Liquid Lipcolour
      $22.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (671)
    • 12 colors
      New Shades
      NEW! Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil Easy Shape & Fill
      $24.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (142)
    • 29 colors
      Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Lipstick
      $20.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (835)
    • 24 colors
      Smashbox Always On Liquid Lipstick, Matte
      $24.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (249)
    • Benefit Cosmetics BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara
      $25.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (259)
    • tarte Sex Kitten Liquid Eyeliner
      $20.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (12)
    • 8 colors
      Smashbox Photo Edit Eye Shadow Trio
      $22.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (28)
    • 16 colors
      Urban Decay Hi-Fi Shine Ultra Cushion Lipgloss
      $20.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (82)
    • Tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight
      $20.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (59)
    • 20 colors
      Buxom Cosmetics Va-Va Plump Shiny Liquid Lipstick
      $20.00
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as a Star Rewards member to earn
      Earn bonus points NOW! Earn bonus points NOW!
      Free shipping at $75
      Free Shipping & Returns with $75 Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping at $75 Free shipping at $75
      (454)
    • Showing All 17 Items