I must have been using this mascara for about a decade now. Whenever I've tried others Im always so disappointed, none of them match up! This benefit mascara definitely has the best wand out of all of them in my opinion, it doesn't clump like the others I've tried, goes on nicely and isn't too runny or smudgy- perfect!

My favorite non-irritating mascara! Never clumps and looks terrific. I try others and always come back to this one.

I can’t use this because it is so old it want come out the tubes .

The best mascarra I have ever used and Ive tried them all. It doesnt clump! Adds volume and stays put. Wouldnt buy anything else.

This mascara some how makes my lashes have less volume than I started with. It clumps my lashes together and I end up with panda eyes after a few hours. Worst mascara I have ever used and totally not worth the money. Avoid

My lashes have thinned out as I've aged. This is the best mascara I've found to make my lashes look thicker and longer. I just found it a month ago and love it!

I love Benefit make up and love roller lash and "they're real" but gutted with this mascara. The brush is too big and very messy to put on. Goes all over my eyelids every time. It feels sticky when in and makes my eye lashers stick together, very uncomfortable. Volume doesn't last and I end up with panda eyes! Definitely not worth the price! Complete waste of money.

I have been using this mascara for 6 years now- it's amazing. I've never worn fake lashes but everyone always asks if I'm wearing them. Honestly if this product was ever discontinued I would cry myself to sleep for months!