I normally wear a size 7.5 and have small calf. I order a size 8 but it's too big for my feet. There was at least 1 - 1.5 inch left. It leaves plenty of room around the calf. I love the material that it does not look like rain boot so I can wear it with any outfit! And the best is that black goes well with any colors! Awesome material , just disappointed at the sizing.

I had been hanging on to my old beloved Sam Edelman rain boots for years, but they had a huge rip in them and it was time to move on. I am a thin woman but boots rarely fit my calves - I almost always have to buy "wide calf." I am normally a size 7.5 shoe, and an 8-8.5 boot. The size 8 in these are perfect!! Any smaller in the calf and they probably wouldn't work (on me), but they hug my calf perfectly and still fit with fluffy socks and jeans. The detailing is beautiful, and the straps around the boot and on the back really make it stand out. Yes, it's an equestrian style, but it's not costume-y. I love these even more than my last pair - no regrets here! I hope these last for a long, long time.

I bought it for my daughter, she like this boots, comfortable and pretty

Yes, they've got lots of classy style and don't look like galoshes. There's really nice, clean detailing too (zoom in on the pic to see what looks like real stitching at seams!) For rainboots, they're probably adequately comfortable, but they have the usual rainboot "sloshy fit." They thunked when I walked. I returned them because another pair fit my needs better. The other ones have a brown top cuff (more versatile) and fit my high arches better. It was a tough choice though!

This boots runs big, esp the calf area. Its good for ppl with bigger calf, but it doesnt work for me. The reason I bought this boots online is becoz I need it for rainy days. But somehow it doesnt look like a rain boots to me, it look n feel more like a riding boots. I also dont like the material coz its kinda hard. I returned the boots back to macys.

I got these rainboots because I don't like the look of regular clunky looking rainboots. These came and they were exactly what I wanted. As a matter of fact unless you touch them you can't even tell that they are rubber boots, they look like very nice riding boots. The only think that I don't like is that they are a little bit difficult to get on and off probably because of the slim fit of the shaft.

Wasn't wide enough great look but foot looked long and said wide leg not true

The shaft and footbed was too narrow for my taste, since I tend to wear multiple socks.