I love this boots, it makes your legs skinnier...if you have a BIG CALF....this is not for you. Otherwise, this is great especially with skinny jeans :).

I loved these boots, they were what I was looking for. Unfortunately, they were awful. The first pair I bought, the zipper was bended and dug into my ankle when I walked. I exchaged it, the second pair was worse. The right boot, began to loose its shape and get big. After a couple of weeks, my right foot would slide out of the boot. I stopped wearing them, one boot looked much bigger than the other. I was happy when I was able to return them. This time I got another brand, which was much better.

I am tall with skinny legs AND narrow feet, NONE OF THE OTHER BOOTS OUT THERE FIT, they are all too big and look SO DUMB & CHEAP on my legs!!!!! I am a 9-9.5 and I got an 8.5 in these because I want to wear with thin trouser socks vs thick winter socks and they fit great! I depends on what size sock you want to wear! they are narrow and MY FEET ARE NARROW so I am so happy and cant wait to wear them over and over and really break them in!!!!

I bought them in black and brown because they were advertised as leather. The boots were comfortable and perfect for my average size calves. I could wear them with jeans, skirt or dress. Im 5'9" and the boots hit just below the knee so they were perfect. When I came back to the Macys site to write a review the description of the boot was different and no longer said they were leather. I returned the boots because I wanted leather boots for the price i paid. The Panko boots from Franco Sarto are basically the same style but are leather. Wish they had them available.

I was a bit hesitant to buy these after reading some reviews, but I LOVE these boots. They look great with leggings or jeans. They are really comfortable and look great on. Good buy!

I HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THE PERFECT CLASSIC LOOKING RIDING BOOTS FOR A LONG TIME NOW AND WHEN I FOUND THIS ONLINE I JUST WENT RIGHT AHEAD AND BOUGHT IT. WHEN WORE IT MAN, IT WAS SO NARROW. I WAS ALREADY STRUGGLING TO ZIP THE BOOTS ALL THE WAY UO AND IW AS ONLY WEARING "JEGGINGS AT THAT TIME. I KNEW RIGHT THEN AND THERE THAT I HAD TO RETURN THWM. WOULD BE PERFECT THOUGH FOR GIRLS WITH SKINNY LEGS.

Bought these boots last fall and still absolutely love them. I do not understand the negative reviews? They are very comfortable and I can wear them all day. I did not notice that they are not real leather... could have fooled me! I was in the airport (on a cross country trip) and got two compliments on the boots this weekend... they still look brand new. I have average size calves and did not have a problem tucking in my jeans into the boots and zipping them up. Would recommend these boots and feel that they are worth the price.

I was excited about these but when I tried them on, I too noticed the skinny calf, I had to force the zipper up my leg. They are also a little uncomfortable, these will be returned.