[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Love these boots!! Great quality, beautiful cognac brown color. I didn’t give 5 stars because it is very difficult to get your foot passed the ankle section of the boot the first several times you wear them, like very difficult; you begin sweating trying to get these on, but don’t quit because they’re fabulous looking once on! I’m thin, 5’8” 135lbs., I have narrow calves and feet, and it was still difficult to get passed the ankle of the boot. The first wear the leather was a little stiff around the footbed area, but by my second wear, I felt like I’d owned these boots for years, they were super comfortable. I’m between a size 8.5 -9.0, so I ordered the 9; I definitely have room in the toe area and probably could’ve gotten the 8.5, but thicker socks or an insole would remedy this issue. These are so well made: Melissa button 2. I will buy again from Frye for sure!