This eyeliner always remains my favorite no matter how many others I try. It lasts the longest and doesn't smudge. It is by far the longest pencil, too, so the pencil lasts a very long time.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This eyeliner glides on & lasts all day . No irritation. This is the only brand I will use !

Love this eyeliner. I've been wearing it for over a decade and I plan to continue.

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used I got stressed out when I thought Macys didn't carry it anymore. Easy application with beautiful results and stays in place even though not waterproof.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Easy to use stays on smooth putting on Last a long time since it’s so long

This pencil is easy to apply and long wearing throughout the day.

I’ve used only this pencil for years and years. It’s actually dark brown, so don’t let the “black coffee” deter you from ordering😉

Best waterline eyeliner ever