WHY-MAC-WHY?!? I've been using NC15/NW20 for quite a few years now. It was perfect for minimizing redness around my lips and covering brokeken capillaries under my nose, and that's just to name a couple of my major uses. I had concealing pencil that offered precision, blendable coverage, and was always in my bag. There are certain products you just don't mess with or discontinue...this was one of them :(

Great pencil for inner eye rim. So much better than stark white. Makes me look more awake.

This pencil is perfect for covering up moles and freckles!!!! It's a time saver and provides great coverage. I haven't used it for my waterline, but I love it for those little spots!

I had a friend recommend a pencil similar to this, but decided to try the MAC one instead. I love how it opens up the eye and looks so natural! It's something I never thought I would need, but now I notice a great difference when I don't use it. It also glides on very nicely, and is pretty long wearing.

Stays on for the majority of the day. I have the NARS one in the same color. MAC's works way better!

As a MAC Pro artist, I grab this pencil all the time, almost daily. I use it on a lot of models, from teens, grandmas, and in everyone in between. I've used many nude shade liners and this remains my fave. Plus, it's available in 3 shades, so you can be sure to find one that suits your skintone... Strip your white liner and go nude. ;)

not for me.... watched so many Youtube videos on the best way to open up the eye. I don't find this does that for me at all. It's a nice soft pencil even so soft it sits in my very dark lower lashes. Would like it in a dark brown though! It's probably me... yet it was not at all flattering on my water line.

This is my all time favorite Nude eyeliner for the waterline. I rarely put anything besides a nude in my waterline so I reach for this pencil everyday. It's super creamy so you don't have to worry about it tugging or dragging on your sensitive eye area. Once it sets it does not budge on me. The coverage is extremly opaque it instantly brightens and opens up my eyes. Like I said I use this everyday even on days with little to no makeup this makes a huge change. Definitly try this pencil if you love a good nude. I always have an extra on standby.