Bought the boots because it said they run a wide calf, when I got them I was not able to get them over my calf (I wear a size 5.5 in womens with a 17" calf) Very disappointed about the shaft as I am often since cute over the knee boots dont always cater to wide calfs.

The quality is awesome BUT for a slender gal like me, the boots did not stay on the calves and that was very disappointing. Outside of that it was true to color and nice.

My daughter so loves these They look very good with jeans and dress pants So you can wears these with just about everything and not go wrong.

These are not true over-the-knee, the fabric looked at little cheap for a Macy's product and yes I returned them!

Would definitely recommend. Fits true to size and comfortable!

Definitely not worth the money. I wasn't even able to get these boots on, they were extremely tight on my calf, and the portion that goes above your knee is also extremely tight. Even after opening the laces as far as possible. I was very disappointed by this purchase.

Love love love these boots, brought them in two colors. Comfortable and beautiful on. Fit is perfect.

Bought these when they were on sale I wear them so much very comfy and cute I wear them with leggings and rompers. I get lots of compliments on them