Macy's Presents: The Edit- A curated mix of fashion and inspiration Check It Out
Free Shipping with $99 purchase + Free Store Pickup. Contiguous US. Exclusions
  • Our best prices for any budget, Gifts Under $25, Shop All Gifts By Price, Back to The Gift Guide Shop all gifts by price Back to the Gift Guide
  • 26 items in Makeup Gifts Under $25

                    
                
    • Filter
    • Sort By
    • All Items (26)
    • Free Pick Up
    • Sort by
    • 2 colors
      Lancôme Monsieur Big Mascara, 0.33 oz
      $25.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (950)
    • Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (444)
    • Tarte Hamptons Weekender Contour Palette
      $23.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (11)
    • 2 colors
      Benefit Cosmetics they're real! lengthening mascara, 0.3 oz
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (1287)
    • 29 colors
      Lancôme L'Absolu Gloss, 0.27 oz.
      $25.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (27)
    • 24 colors
      Smashbox Always On Liquid Lipstick, Matte, 0.13 oz
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (242)
    • 14 colors
      Stila Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (22)
    • Tarte Tartelette Flirt Palette
      $23.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
    • 5 colors
      Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion - Original
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (8453)
    • Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray, 1 oz
      $15.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (441)
    • Too Faced Better Than Sex Mini Mascara
      $12.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (444)
    • 10 colors
      bareMinerals Moxie Plumping Lipgloss
      $18.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (42)
    • Anastasia Beverly Hills Lip Primer
      $16.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (43)
    • Too Faced Deluxe Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara, 0.17 oz
      $12.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (75)
    • Urban Decay Troublemaker Mascara
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (1033)
    • 4 colors
      Lancôme Ombré Hypnôse Mini Chubby Shadow Stick
      $19.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (7)
    • 3 colors
      INGLOT Liquid Eyeliner
      $13.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (16)
    • 26 colors
      NARS Precision Lip Liner
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
    • 3 colors
      Smashbox Pucker Up Lipstick Palette
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (3)
    • Peter Thomas Roth Lashes To Die For The Masacara
      $22.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (30)
    • 11 colors
      Buxom Cosmetics Big & Sexy Bold Gel Lipstick
      $22.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (18)
    • 8 colors
      NUDESTIX Gel Color Lip + Cheek Balm
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (6)
    • Too Faced Melted Gold Liquified Gold Lip Gloss
      $21.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      (3)
    • TONYMOLY Kiss Kiss Lip Essence Balm
      $10.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Frame With $75 Online Beauty Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Earn bonus points NOW!
      Checkout as Star Rewards Member - get bonus points
      Earn bonus points NOW!