{"product":[{"id":14437697,"identifier":{"productUrl":"/shop/product/make-up-for-ever-the-professionall-pro-routine-volumizing-mascara?ID=14437697","productId":14437697,"topLevelCategoryID":"290756","topLevelCategoryName":"Beauty"},"department":{"departmentId":643,"departmentName":"CLOSED-NAILS"},"division":{"id":41,"name":"TREND COSMETICS"},"messages":{"info":[{}]},"detail":{"name":"The ProfessionAll Pro Routine Volumizing Mascara","description":"An easy-to-use 24-hour ultra-black, waterproof and smudge-proof felt-tip liquid eyeliner for classic lines and graphic looks.","secondaryDescription":"","seoKeywords":"MAKE UP FOR EVER, Make Up For Ever The ProfessionAll Pro Routine Volumizing Mascara","flags":{"chanel":false,"hermes":false,"coach":false,"hasWarranty":false,"bigTicketItem":false,"phoneOnly":false,"registrable":true,"masterProduct":false,"memberProduct":false,"gwpIndicator":false,"truefitEligible":false,"fitPredictorEligible":false,"isStoreOnlyProductOnline":false,"eligibleForPreOrder":false,"countryEligible":true,"hasColors":false,"rebates":false,"giftCard":false,"suppressColorSwatches":false,"hasColorSwatches":false,"beauty":true,"hasAdditionalImages":true,"bigTicketV2CItem":false,"onlineExclusive":false,"storeOnlySpecial":false,"finishLine":false,"sitewidesale":false,"protectionPlanEligible":false,"bannerForKidsChokeHazard":false,"sizePersistForMen":false,"bigTicketDeliveryFeeRestructureEligible":true,"dimensionsCopyGroupEnabled":false,"materialCareSectionEnabled":false,"sizeAndFitEnabled":false,"arBeauty":false,"arFurniture":false,"virtualTryOn":false,"experience3D":false,"experience360":false,"backInStockOptOut":false,"consolidatedProductComplex":false,"writeAReviewRedesignExpEnabled":false,"siteMonetizationProduct":true,"consolidatedMaster":false,"processedProdDesc":false,"esecRemoveSecureUserTokenQueryParamEnabled":true,"pickUpStore":true,"hasCustomColors":false,"zeekitEnabled":false,"sizeChartExperienceEnabled":false,"altModelSizesExperimentEnabled":false,"bcomsyndigoEnabled":false,"seeMoreAndSizeChartExperienceEnabled":false,"styleMeEnabled":false,"seeMoreExperienceEnabled":false,"gwpExperienceEnabled":false,"PDPColorized":true,"isEligibleForColorwayPromoBadging":false,"isFewLeftMessageRedesignEnabled":true,"isTrueFitSizeAutoSelectEnabled":true,"klarnaEligible":true,"modiFaceEligible":false,"isPdpBVReviewFormUpdatesEnabled":true,"phase2DesktopBVApiTrt1Enabled":false,"phase2DesktopBVApiTrt2Enabled":false,"phase2MobileBVApiTrt1Enabled":false,"homeFOB":false,"isSubscriptionExperienceEligible":false,"isMarketPlaceEligible":false,"isNew":false,"isLilyAIEnabled":false,"is3VTypeDrivenConsolidated":false,"isReviewPhotosUploadEnabled":true,"isSplitThirdVariant":false,"isLegalDisclosureRequired":false,"isBestSeller":false,"isExclusiveBrand":false,"is3VSizeDrivenConsolidated":false,"isFindationEnabled":false,"isBeautyGiftSet":false,"isConsolidatedThirdVariant":false,"isWebCollageOutFromTabs":true,"isVideoImageRailEnabled":true,"isTrueCollectionsEnabled":false,"isLTLScheduledDeliveryEnabled":false},"reviewStatistics":{},"questionAnswer":{"questionCount":0,"answerCount":0},"orderedMasterGroupList":[],"memberDisplayGroupsMap":{},"bulletText":["WHAT IT DOES:","Nonstop ink flow and a flexible tip provide the ultimate ease and versatility, from classic lines to graphic looks","Waterproof, smudge-proof and perspiration-proof","Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers","HOW TO USE:","Classic Liner: With eye open and looking straight into mirror, use side of applicator to mark desired thickness in center of eye; using tip, connect from inner corner to center of eye; connect from outer corner to center without extending too far out","Winged Liner: Start by applying Classic Liner technique referenced above, then follow lower lash line in an upward angle and use side of applicator to connect from outer eye toward center in one sweeping motion; use tip to perfect line on eye","Pro Tip: For down-turned eyes, add a small wing on outer corner to create a lifted look, and for smaller eyes, stay close to lash line for a more defined effect"],"maxQuantity":6,"typeName":"MAKEUP","additionalImagesCount":2,"numberOfColors":0,"brand":{"name":"MAKE UP FOR EVER","id":113106,"url":"/shop/brands/make-up-for-ever?id=58468","subBrand":"","brandBreakout":true,"brandBlocked":false},"bulletLinks":[],"pdfEmailDescription":"Make Up For Ever The ProfessionAll Pro Routine Volumizing Mascara","skinCareType":"","memberProductCount":0,"completeName":"Make Up For Ever The ProfessionAll Pro Routine Volumizing Mascara","klarna":{"klarnaDataClientId":"8561a670-d195-5128-9ab7-b4c9ec7ec2fb","klarnaOnsiteJsSdkPath":"https://na-library.klarnaservices.com/lib.js"},"salesFloorBrand":{"salesFloorBrandUrl":"","salesFloorBrand":false}},"shipping":{"giftWrapMessage":"Our Normal Gift Boxing is not available for this item.","notes":["California and Minnesota customers call 1-800-289-6229 for Free Shipping information."],"freeShippingMessages":["This item qualifies for Free Shipping with minimum purchase!"]},"relationships":{"taxonomy":{"categories":[{"name":"Beauty","url":"https://www.macys.com/shop/beauty?id=290756","type":"rootcategory","id":290756},{"name":"Mascara","url":"https://www.macys.com/shop/beauty/makeup/eye/mascara?id=53452","type":"homecategory","id":53452}],"defaultCategoryId":53452}},"imagery":{"images":[{"filePath":"1/optimized/22151161_fpx.tif","name":"22151161.fpx","showJumboSwatch":false,"swatchSpriteOffset":0,"swatchSpriteUrlIndex":0},{"filePath":"1/optimized/22151221_fpx.tif","name":"22151221.fpx","showJumboSwatch":false,"swatchSpriteOffset":62,"swatchSpriteUrlIndex":0},{"filePath":"6/optimized/22151226_fpx.tif","name":"22151226.fpx","showJumboSwatch":false,"swatchSpriteOffset":124,"swatchSpriteUrlIndex":0}],"smallImagesSprites":{"spriteUrls":["?&$b=MCY/swatches/&hei=75&wid=186&cropN=0,0,3,1&resMode=sharp2&fmt=jpeg&qlt=100,0&layer=0&size=186,75&anchor=0,0&layer=1&size=60,75&src=is{$b$1/optimized/22151161_fpx.tif}&anchor=0,0&posN=0.000000,0&layer=2&size=60,75&src=is{$b$1/optimized/22151221_fpx.tif}&anchor=0,0&posN=0.333333,0&layer=3&size=60,75&src=is{$b$6/optimized/22151226_fpx.tif}&anchor=0,0&posN=0.666667,0"],"imagesWidth":60,"imagesHeight":75,"imagesPerSprite":16}},"availability":{"checkInStoreEligibility":false,"available":false,"lowAvailability":false,"bopsAvailability":false,"bossAvailability":false,"storeAvailability":false},"traits":{"colors":{},"traitsMaps":{"upcMap":{}}},"protectionPlans":[],"urlTemplate":{"swatchSprite":"https://slimages.macysassets.com/is/image/MCY/","product":"https://slimages.macysassets.com/is/image/MCY/products/","video":"https://slimages.macysassets.com/is/content/MacysInc/","swatch":"https://slimages.macysassets.com/is/image/MCY/swatches/","videoPoster":"https://slimages.macysassets.com/is/image/MacysInc/"},"ccfp":{"ccfpEligible":false,"chargePlanPDPDeptDetails":{}},"holidayMessageEligible":false,"productReviews":[{"productId":14437697,"name":"Make Up For Ever The ProfessionAll Pro Routine Volumizing Mascara","description":"An easy-to-use 24-hour ultra-black, waterproof and smudge-proof felt-tip liquid eyeliner for classic lines and graphic looks.","productPageUrl":"https://www.macys.com/shop/product/make-up-for-ever-the-professionall-pro-routine-volumizing-mascara?ID=14437697","imageUrl":"1/optimized/22151161_fpx.tif","reviewFamilyProducts":[18867883,14437697],"reviewStatistics":{"averageOverallRating":4.2,"ratingPercentage":84.0,"overallRatingRange":5,"ratingDistribution":[{"count":8,"ratingValue":1},{"count":11,"ratingValue":2},{"count":54,"ratingValue":3},{"count":96,"ratingValue":4},{"count":171,"ratingValue":5}],"totalReviewCount":340,"helpfulVoteCount":10,"recommendedCount":9,"notRecommendedCount":5,"ratingsOnlyReviewCount":1,"reviewSources":["BV"],"averageSliders":{"Oil":{"value":4.0,"valueLabel":"Neutral","maxLabel":"Moisturizing","label":"Oil-absorbing/Moisturizing","secondaryRatingsId":"Oil","valueRange":7,"minLabel":"Oil-absorbing","displayType":"SLIDER","midLabel":"Neutral"},"Wear":{"value":4.0,"valueLabel":"Neutral","maxLabel":"Long Lasting","label":"Natural wear/Long lasting","secondaryRatingsId":"Wear","valueRange":7,"minLabel":"Natural Wear","displayType":"SLIDER","midLabel":"Neutral"},"SheerBold":{"value":4.0,"valueLabel":"neutral","maxLabel":"Bold","label":"Sheer/Bold","secondaryRatingsId":"SheerBold","valueRange":7,"minLabel":"Sheer","displayType":"SLIDER","midLabel":"neutral"}}},"paginatedReviews":{"total":339,"limit":8,"offset":0,"reviews":[{"reviewId":179739490,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"10502660","userNickname":"Kara1","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"Great Super Black Mascara","reviewText":"This is the only true deep black mascara I have found that does not run.  Other mascaras are a softer black that are a bit dull","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","hasPhotos":false,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"makeupforever.com","logoImageUrl":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86YXR0cmlidXRpb25sb2dvMg/50242abb-0f62-4011-8bd3-43b4b4b66aa6"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Feb 12, 2026","incentivizedReview":false},{"reviewId":177528641,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"zkvsdyiikjzpdmi8pimj01ie5r","userNickname":"SaraB","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"I Won’t Go Without!","reviewText":"This mascara out performs any other to lengthen, separate and to give that wow factor I have been looking for.","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","hasPhotos":false,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"makeupforever.com","logoImageUrl":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86YXR0cmlidXRpb25sb2dvMg/50242abb-0f62-4011-8bd3-43b4b4b66aa6"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Nov 05, 2025","incentivizedReview":false},{"reviewId":177131538,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"11036407","userNickname":"Giavanna","userLocation":"Nj","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":true,"title":"LashLovely","reviewText":"So easy to use delivers terrific look no clumping a stand out product for any occasion.","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","hasPhotos":false,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"makeupforever.com","logoImageUrl":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86YXR0cmlidXRpb25sb2dvMg/50242abb-0f62-4011-8bd3-43b4b4b66aa6"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Oct 17, 2025","incentivizedReview":false},{"reviewId":177130969,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"11166257","userNickname":"Carolina S","userLocation":"Miami, fl","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":1,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"Terrible product","reviewText":"One brush broke and it’s  detached from the container","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","hasPhotos":false,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"clientResponses":[{"response":"We are very sorry to hear this! Please reach us at our Contact page via MAKEUPFOREVER.com in order to promptly assist with your product.","department":"Customer Service","responseSource":"mc-api","date":"Oct 21, 2025","sourceClientName":"makeupforever.com"}],"syndicationSource":{"name":"makeupforever.com","logoImageUrl":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86YXR0cmlidXRpb25sb2dvMg/50242abb-0f62-4011-8bd3-43b4b4b66aa6"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Oct 17, 2025","incentivizedReview":false},{"reviewId":294495071,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"376446091","userNickname":"Macklady","userLocation":"Macomb MI","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":3,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"Drooping","reviewText":"Eyelashes drooped mid day, hard to remove with waterproof eye make-up remover.","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"dataValuesJSONMap":{},"contentLocale":"en_US","hasPhotos":false,"secondaryRatings":{"Oil":{"value":4.0,"valueLabel":"Neutral","maxLabel":"Moisturizing","label":"Oil-absorbing/Moisturizing","secondaryRatingsId":"Oil","valueRange":7,"minLabel":"Oil-absorbing","displayType":"SLIDER"},"Wear":{"value":4.0,"valueLabel":"Neutral","maxLabel":"Long Lasting","label":"Natural wear/Long lasting","secondaryRatingsId":"Wear","valueRange":7,"minLabel":"Natural Wear","displayType":"SLIDER"},"SheerBold":{"value":4.0,"valueLabel":"neutral","maxLabel":"Bold","label":"Sheer/Bold","secondaryRatingsId":"SheerBold","valueRange":7,"minLabel":"Sheer","displayType":"SLIDER"}},"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicated":false,"submissionTime":"Sep 19, 2025","incentivizedReview":false},{"reviewId":175664648,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"11142481","userNickname":"Anelee","userLocation":"San Diego CA","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":true,"title":"The Professional Mascara","reviewText":"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this mascara, as someone who struggles with lashes falling down this mascara has then up all day","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","hasPhotos":false,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"makeupforever.com","logoImageUrl":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86YXR0cmlidXRpb25sb2dvMg/50242abb-0f62-4011-8bd3-43b4b4b66aa6"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Aug 22, 2025","incentivizedReview":false},{"reviewId":293019708,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"tjvz5uk4xsghyxh5v0h4aandm","userNickname":"Zee","userLocation":"New York","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"Best mascara!","reviewText":"The best mascara I ever had! Makes my lashes look fuller","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"dataValuesJSONMap":{},"contentLocale":"en_US","hasPhotos":false,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicated":false,"submissionTime":"Jul 27, 2025","incentivizedReview":false},{"reviewId":174690840,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"11113443","userNickname":"Meggie","userLocation":"Laurel, MD","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":3,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":true,"title":"New bestie","reviewText":"Love this mascara. It goes in smoothly and stays put all day long with out flaking. It washes off easily with soap and water.","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","hasPhotos":false,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"makeupforever.com","logoImageUrl":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86YXR0cmlidXRpb25sb2dvMg/50242abb-0f62-4011-8bd3-43b4b4b66aa6"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Jun 28, 2025","incentivizedReview":false}]},"reviewsWithPhotos":{"totalReviewsWithPhotos":51,"totalPhotos":85,"limitPhotos":12,"offsetPhotos":0,"reviews":[{"reviewId":160019320,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"inf2249756","userNickname":"leonort4","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"It ok","reviewText":"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I got this in the mail!! I use both steps the product is on the only thing is that is not good when you go to the pool or the beach because it comes off it’s a okay mascara..","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","photos":[{"photoId":"4395294","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/de17a0c3-ae71-5330-bf8a-3dbed68965df","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/c997baec-8b45-5a03-a873-2fcce8d39e22","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}}],"hasPhotos":true,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"influenster.com","logoImageUrl":"https://contentorigin.bazaarvoice.com/influenster/default/influenster.png"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Sep 22, 2023","incentivizedReview":true},{"reviewId":160019318,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"inf9899333","userNickname":"amandah562","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"Makeup forever","reviewText":"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My incentive on this maskra is \"Love love love\"!!!! Love how the brush applicator is small it gets all the lashes easy and simple. Very affordable price.. But it stays all day and makes my lashes look amazing... I didn't think I would like the little brush but once I tried it I completely changed my mind. Its an easy two step process. Its clearly labeled easy to apply but the outcome is stunning. My lashes look so long and full","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","photos":[{"photoId":"4395290","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/b1eaf43f-bd13-5d6c-96ab-3290f20020fe","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/6e9e0dee-4192-5514-ac39-40a7ccc8b013","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}},{"photoId":"4395291","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/1ca9028b-d705-54d6-a674-88f6b1e55745","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/5418d8b9-5a26-5ea9-b61c-19ddfaf61b86","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}},{"photoId":"4395292","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/5bb046fc-609f-5d49-8d1b-374b0635095c","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/4ddd4ed8-9c43-520c-a88d-66b49eddcb2b","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}},{"photoId":"4395293","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/7971892d-e3ad-5ad6-b353-1781155d19fa","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/01ba665f-9b72-5c74-9020-d3799449e1f1","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}}],"hasPhotos":true,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"influenster.com","logoImageUrl":"https://contentorigin.bazaarvoice.com/influenster/default/influenster.png"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Sep 22, 2023","incentivizedReview":true},{"reviewId":160019316,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"inf9586429","userNickname":"sallyc43","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":4,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"Wonderful VOLUMIZING Mascara","reviewText":"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I Received this Complementary from Influenster for my honest feedback.  I just like the 2 step process. The MAKE UP FOR EVER PROFESSIONALL Mascara is a 2 step application.. 1st lifts & separates the lashes and 2nd adds volume. I like the fact the brushes are soft and easy to apply. In addition, I found the product adds volume to my lashes. No clumps. 24 hour wear.. & definitely waterproof which is great if your outside or in the water. See photos Rt.eye shows the product on.. Lt.. Eye without product. The only issue I have is with the strait brushes.","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","photos":[{"photoId":"4395286","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/1b36dda2-f60f-5faf-be21-665af2732882","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/d5d23485-80b4-58d4-bea5-bab6cbce7aa1","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}},{"photoId":"4395287","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/827a38e4-fc17-5889-ac83-b5dddb38fdfb","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/9d9fd655-afae-5872-a29e-ec5ce9056dc4","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}},{"photoId":"4395288","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/e430b5ae-22f8-5632-ab8b-8d21022fc84b","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/7531c29c-53ee-513c-bf00-d6b9bf5de263","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}},{"photoId":"4395289","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/a4f49967-bc74-58f3-92ca-e3f087038a74","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/4b07f8bd-2245-5cbd-9c88-c52743fd8e8a","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}}],"hasPhotos":true,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"influenster.com","logoImageUrl":"https://contentorigin.bazaarvoice.com/influenster/default/influenster.png"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Sep 22, 2023","incentivizedReview":true},{"reviewId":160019314,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"inf9702004","userNickname":"probablystenlee","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"Good everyday mascara","reviewText":"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This mascara is good for an everyday more natural look. I like that it doesn’t smear or clump too much. I wish it lengthened my lashes more but still a good product!","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","photos":[{"photoId":"4395285","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/ebb9be8b-84fa-5c99-8fb2-03e37b1a4326","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/8dbb53f0-aa65-5240-8003-fb1426554404","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}}],"hasPhotos":true,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"influenster.com","logoImageUrl":"https://contentorigin.bazaarvoice.com/influenster/default/influenster.png"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Sep 22, 2023","incentivizedReview":true},{"reviewId":160019309,"productId":14437697,"authorId":"inf5758419","userNickname":"patriciap80df","ratingsOnly":false,"rating":5,"ratingRange":5,"recommended":false,"title":"Amazing Marscara","reviewText":"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I've tried other masks, I can say for sure that this one is the best, the small brush and the first step are perfect to give me a natural look. My lashes became longer and voluminous. I will definitely use and buy again.","totalFeedbackCount":0,"totalPositiveFeedbackCount":0,"totalNegativeFeedbackCount":0,"featured":false,"contentLocale":"en_US","photos":[{"photoId":"4395283","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/c696fc2f-fc82-5ff5-bb58-3c0d7cc845a1","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/8825f90a-55ab-5cf5-9d93-64bb874524bf","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}},{"photoId":"4395284","sizes":{"normal":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/9c23ebc1-570d-55ff-b442-e3ef67ed60bd","sizeId":"medium"},"thumbnail":{"url":"https://photos-us.bazaarvoice.com/photo/2/cGhvdG86bWFrZXVwZm9yZXZlci11cw/006d18e9-b518-5158-a891-539fc145194c","sizeId":"thumbnail"}}}],"hasPhotos":true,"topContributor":false,"anonymous":false,"syndicationSource":{"name":"influenster.com","logoImageUrl":"https://contentorigin.bazaarvoice.com/influenster/default/influenster.png"},"syndicated":true,"submissionTime":"Sep 22, 2023","incentivizedReview":true}]},"generatedSummary":{"summary":"* This mascara is generally well-received, with a two-step design that helps lift, separate, and add volume to lashes.\n* Many users found the approach effective, and the mascara is praised for its long-lasting wear without smudging or flaking.\n* However, some users reported issues with the second step wand, finding it clumpy and difficult to apply, resulting in an undesirable \"spider leg\" look.\n* Overall, the mascara provides a natural, lifted, and volumized look, but may not be suitable for those seeking a more dramatic lash effect.","type":"TEXT","title":"REVIEW_SUMMARY","detail":"BULLET_FORMAT_SUMMARY","disclaimer":"This summary is generated by artificial intelligence based on customer reviews"}}]}],"meta":{"tags":{"canonical":"/shop/product/make-up-for-ever-the-professionall-pro-routine-volumizing-mascara?ID=14437697"},"analytics":{"data":{"page_type":"product","t_category_id":["53452"],"t_category_name":["Mascara"],"is_big_ticket":["false"],"is_big_ticket_v2c":["false"],"product_id":["14437697"],"product_low_availability":["false"],"product_availability_message":["This product is currently unavailable"],"product_name":["The ProfessionAll Pro Routine Volumizing Mascara"],"product_type":["single item"],"product_original_price":["0"],"product_shipping_surcharge":["0.0"],"product_price":["0"],"product_pricing_state":["ZERO"],"product_rating":["4.2"],"product_reviews":["340"],"product_video":["false"],"product_gwp_available":[],"product_pwp_available":[],"true_fit_eligible":["false"],"findation_eligible":["false"],"product_brand":["MAKE UP FOR EVER"],"consolidated_product":"false","gdp_eligible":"false"}},"soastapageinfo":{"site":"GCP","appserver":"UNKNOWN_CLONE","timestamp":"04/15/2026 12:52:40 EDT","release":"localhost","releaseDate":"2026-04-01T16:08:03.529Z","version":"3.220.0"}},"productMktData":{"@context":"http://schema.org","@type":"Product","name":"The ProfessionAll Pro Routine Volumizing Mascara","category":"Beauty","brand":{"@type":"Brand","name":"MAKE UP FOR EVER"},"image":["https://slimages.macysassets.com/is/image/MCY/products/1/optimized/22151161_fpx.tif","https://slimages.macysassets.com/is/image/MCY/products/1/optimized/22151221_fpx.tif","https://slimages.macysassets.com/is/image/MCY/products/6/optimized/22151226_fpx.tif"],"productID":14437697,"url":"https://www.macys.com/shop/product/make-up-for-ever-the-professionall-pro-routine-volumizing-mascara?ID=14437697","description":"An easy-to-use 24-hour ultra-black, waterproof and smudge-proof felt-tip liquid eyeliner for classic lines and graphic looks.","offers":[{"@type":"Offer","price":"0.00","priceCurrency":"USD","availability":"http://schema.org/OutOfStock"}],"reviews":[{"@type":"Review","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Kara1"},"datePublished":"2026-02-12","name":"Great Super Black Mascara","description":"This is the only true deep black mascara I have found that does not run.  Other mascaras are a softer black that are a bit dull","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","bestRating":"5","ratingValue":5,"worstRating":"1"}},{"@type":"Review","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"SaraB"},"datePublished":"2025-11-05","name":"I Won’t Go Without!","description":"This mascara out performs any other to lengthen, separate and to give that wow factor I have been looking for.","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","bestRating":"5","ratingValue":5,"worstRating":"1"}},{"@type":"Review","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Giavanna"},"datePublished":"2025-10-17","name":"LashLovely","description":"So easy to use delivers terrific look no clumping a stand out product for any occasion.","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","bestRating":"5","ratingValue":5,"worstRating":"1"}},{"@type":"Review","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Carolina S"},"datePublished":"2025-10-17","name":"Terrible product","description":"One brush broke and it’s  detached from the container","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","bestRating":"5","ratingValue":1,"worstRating":"1"}},{"@type":"Review","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Macklady"},"datePublished":"2025-09-19","name":"Drooping","description":"Eyelashes drooped mid day, hard to remove with waterproof eye make-up remover.","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","bestRating":"5","ratingValue":3,"worstRating":"1"}},{"@type":"Review","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Anelee"},"datePublished":"2025-08-22","name":"The Professional Mascara","description":"[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this mascara, as someone who struggles with lashes falling down this mascara has then up all day","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","bestRating":"5","ratingValue":5,"worstRating":"1"}},{"@type":"Review","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Zee"},"datePublished":"2025-07-27","name":"Best mascara!","description":"The best mascara I ever had! Makes my lashes look fuller","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","bestRating":"5","ratingValue":5,"worstRating":"1"}},{"@type":"Review","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Meggie"},"datePublished":"2025-06-28","name":"New bestie","description":"Love this mascara. It goes in smoothly and stays put all day long with out flaking. It washes off easily with soap and water.","reviewRating":{"@type":"Rating","bestRating":"5","ratingValue":3,"worstRating":"1"}}],"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","ratingValue":"4.20","reviewCount":"340","bestRating":"5","worstRating":"0"}},"uiKillSwitches":{"isAutoTaggingEnabled":true,"bopsBossCopyUpdateEnabled":false,"fccCategoryURLEnabled":true,"frictionFreeStoreHeaderEnabledPDP":true,"isShippingAndReturnsBadgeEnabled":false,"pzoBadgingEnabled":true,"isInPageSfContextualWidgetEnabled":true,"isUpcColorOverrideEnabled":true,"dressSizeSelectorsEnabled":true,"hexaEnabled":false,"isProductReviewCategoryDataEnabled":false,"fbtEnabled":false,"featureEnabledB":true,"isShoppableDisabled":true,"featureEnabledA":true,"isXAPISchemaProcessing":true,"campaignCategoryIdsEnabled":false,"categoryBreadCrumb":false,"isMediasFragmentEnabled":true,"featureEnabledH":false,"enableGAMImpressionTags":true,"featureEnabledG":true,"featureEnabledF":false,"featureEnabledE":true,"imageARIndicatorEnabled":true,"featureEnabledD":false,"featureEnabledC":false,"isDiscontinuedFCCParameterEnabled":true,"isConsolidatedShoesEnabled":false,"contextualWidgetEnabled":true,"isBigTicketCustomColorSitletEnabled":true,"rviRelatedProsZonesEnabled":true,"pdpSalePercentOffDisplayEnabled":true,"isBVCategoryNameEnabled":false,"isPricePerOzTreatmentEnabled":true,"phase2DesktopBVReviewsApiEnabled":true,"isBeautyCategoryListEnabled":true,"isBeautyFlagBypassedEnabled":true,"isColorwayPricing2":true,"isProductDimensionsForMarketplaceItemsEnabled":true,"isCustomDropdownForColorSwatches":false,"pdpSponsoredItemsContentEnabledServerSide":true,"exposePickupOnlyMembersOfMasterEnabled":false,"isBigTicketCXMasterV2CFromMembersEnabled":false,"isBopsAvailableByLocation404ResponseEnabled":true,"isColorwayPricing1":false,"isModifaceEnabled":true,"isBigTicketAvailabilityViewEnabled":true,"isBigTicketCXSwatchesEnabled":true,"arrivesByDateEnabled":true,"isInteractiveOfferBadgesEnabled":true,"isLoyaltyPPCEnabled":true,"isScrollColorSwatchIntoViewEnabled":false,"tealiumScriptEnabled":true,"surchargeShippingMessageEnabled":true,"zoomInSlideshowImproved":true,"isPDPEnhancementGEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementEEnabled":true,"bigTicketV2CEnabled":true,"bossEnabled":true,"upcPricingForMarketplaceStandardPDPEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementDEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementJEnabled":true,"reviewPhotoUpload":true,"prosFCCFallbackImpressionTagEnabled":false,"isPDPEnhancementMEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementOEnabled":true,"isTrueFitSizeAutoSelectEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementLEnabled":true,"priceBySizeComplexEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementBEnabled":true,"pdpBVReviewFormUpdatesEnabled":true,"isWebCollageOutFromTabs":true,"vendorCustomDeliveryMsg":true,"enableClickTagsForSMProducts":true,"prosImpressionTaggingEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementTEnabled":true,"priceBySizeBigTicketItemsProtectionPlanEnabled":false,"inHouseVideoEnabled":true,"sddPromoEnabled":true,"isSearchEnabled":false,"shopTheLookEnabled":false,"isPDPEnhancementZEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementREnabled":true,"valuePriceLabelEnabled":true,"filterOverlappingProsProducts":true,"v2cBulletTextRemovalEnabled":true,"loggingRedisExceptionsAndReachBackendSystems":false,"breadcrumbAbsolutePathEnabled":true,"isImageEntryEnabled":true,"splitThirdVariantEnabled":true,"isShoeSizeSelectorsEnabled":true,"isAkamaiInventoryCachePurgeEnabled":true,"isRedisInventoryCachePurgeEnabled":true,"isColorwayPromosPhase2Enabled":false,"isIncentivizedReviewValueFieldCheck":true,"isPerformanceINPEnabled":true,"finalPriceDisplayEnabled":true,"isTrueFitModalEnabled":false,"removeFallbackProsZoneEnabled":true,"isPdpProductEngagementPromptTrtTwoEnabled":true,"isSpacingExperimentEnabled":true,"pdpRequestValidatorEnabled":true,"isMkpAutoreplenishmentEnabled":false,"priceBySizeBulletLinksForMemberEnabled":true,"sponsoredItemsEnabled":true,"unavailableConsolidatedMasterFixEnabled":false,"bigTicketDeliveryFeeRestructureEnabled":true,"productPromotionEnabled":true,"isCustomersPurchasedDisable":true,"isPDPEnhancementWEnabled":true,"isBigTicketWebAREnabled":true,"isFewLeftMessageRedesignEnabled":true,"isAutoReplenishmentEnabled":true,"itemAvailabilityOptimizedBOPSExperienceEnabled":true,"categoryDataEnabled":true,"isShopSimilarNavigationEnabled":true,"isRedisCircuitBreakerEnabled":true,"threePcBannerCopyEnabled":false,"checkoutServiceGCPMigrationEnabled":true,"seoWeddingRegistryCanonicalEnabled":true,"additionalShippingDetailsEnabled":true,"copyClarityVueEnabled":true,"enableGAMAdsFromApp":true,"pubSubInventoryAndPriceUpdateLogicEnabled":true,"isNewShippingConstraintMessageEnabled":true,"mltProsStitchesEnabled":false,"isBigTicketCXSwatchesInvisibleRecaptchaEnabled":false,"isCacheControlInResponseHeaderEnabled":false,"isBigTicketHideInStockOfferFeatureEnabled":false,"phase2MobileBVReviewsApiEnabled":true,"updatePriceComponentSequence":true,"isPromoV2Enabled":false,"isUnavailableUPCListEnabled":true,"isProsZoneAHorizontalEnabled":true,"prePurchasePointsCalculationEnabled":true,"isReviewHighlightsAPIEnabled":false,"starPassWithOfferEnabled":true,"arrivesByDateSuppressTier4for1PItemsEnabled":true,"promoEventBadgeLinkEnabled":true,"isCustomerGCPMigrationEnabled":true,"isFindationEnabled":true,"enhanceSameDayDeliveryEnabled":true,"ccfpEnabled":true,"carouselOpenInNewTabEnabled":true,"inStoreCurbsidePickupEnabled":true,"latchkeyMemberProductsBigTicketItemFlagEnabled":true,"pddContingencyEnabled":false,"isFinalPricePromoCopyUpdateEnabled":true,"isColorwayPricingCopyEnabled":true,"enableImpressionTagsForSMProducts":false,"ccfpGCPMigrationEnabled":true,"thirdVariantConsolidatedEnabled":true,"isSizeSmallImageUpdateEnabled":false,"isAutoReplenishNewDropDownEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementUEnabled":true,"usebvReviewService":true,"hidePzo":true,"isProcessedProdDescEnabled":true,"storeOnlySpecialsEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementYEnabled":true,"isUpcLevelPromoBadgingEnabled":true,"gwpConsiderBagItemsForPromo":true,"isPDPEnhancementQEnabled":true,"ocfPickupBOPSOnlyAllProductViewsEnabled":false,"commonStoreLocationEnabled":true,"isLettuceClientEnabledForRedis":false,"additionalFeesEnabled":true,"globalHolidayMessageEnabled":false,"isBopsAvailabilityFixEnabled":true,"klarnaPaymentEnabled":true,"newGoogleAPICallEnabled":true,"enableGAMClickTags":true,"isPDPEnhancementFEnabled":true,"eventBadgingEnabled":true,"topLevelZoomer":true,"mediaEnabled":true,"enablePromoOrLvipCovidCustomMessage":false,"isPDPEnhancementHEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementIEnabled":true,"pdpStyliticsOutFittingWidgetEnabled":true,"isStartCheckoutPostCallEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementCEnabled":true,"hostedAuthenticationEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementKEnabled":true,"videoImageRailEnable":true,"includeSizeAttributesForProsEnabled":true,"isBigTicketCXSeeItInStoreRedesignEnabled":true,"isBigTicketPriceBySizeAvailabilityEnabled":true,"isVerifiedPurchaserBadgeEnabled":false,"isPDPEnhancementNEnabled":true,"isWNMProtectionPlansEnabled":false,"prosFBTTwoProductRecEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementAEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementPEnabled":true,"lilyAIAttributesEnabled":true,"hideBanners":true,"isReviewSummaryEnabled":true,"priceSimplificationEnabled":true,"newGWPEnabled":true,"isPairItWithCopyEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementVEnabled":true,"videoIdDisplayEnabled":true,"storeInPreferenceDatabaseEnabled":false,"loyaltyPromotionBadgeTextEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementXEnabled":false,"persistentLoginEnabled":true,"writeAReviewRedesignEnabled":true,"isBrandCategoryUrlEnabled":true,"isGWPEnabled":true,"isKlarnaCustomModalCloseFocusEnabled":false,"isPurgeAkamaiCacheInBatchModeEnabled":true,"deliveryDaysEnabled":true,"isImageIndicatorStylingEnabled":true,"isColorwayPromosEnabled":false,"ccfpCacheEnabled":true,"isConsolidatedMasterPageEnabled":false,"isMcomBigTicketSeeItInStoreEnabled":true,"mainImageAutoplayEnabled":true,"isBigTicketCXProtectionPlansEnabled":false,"isKeyWordChipsFeatureEnabled":true,"enableClientSideMemberListPerfImprovement":true,"globalPreciseDeliveryDateEnabled":true,"rewardBadgeForDigitalEnabled":true,"isDRSPageLoadCacheEnabled":true,"esecRemoveSecureUserTokenQueryParamEnabled":true,"pddOrderMethodsExclusionEnabled":false,"csPagesOnIBMEnabled":false,"newPlacesDetailsApiEnabled":true,"isSplitPerksEnabled":true,"trueCollectionsEnabled":true,"isPDPEnhancementSEnabled":true,"arrivesByDateVdfMkpEnabled":true,"isSyndigoScriptUpdateEnabled":true,"arrivesByDateWithoutLocationEnabled":true,"marketPlaceEnabled":true}}