Benefit CosmeticsBoi-ing Cakeless Full-Coverage Waterproof Concealer
Product details
Web ID: 17472544Unmixed coloring?
I ordered 3 of these in shade "3" a couple months ago. I just opened one and there is discoloration at the top of the tube. I opened the other 2 and same thing. Never seen this before and a little disappointed. I've used this product before and never had this issue. It makes me worry that the product isn't going to be good.
Customer review from Benefit Cosmetics en_US
Conceals Imperfections
This product conceals pimples and skin discolorations.
Recommends this product
Color Oxidized Before Using
I purchased their concealer in December, it's now Jan and I opened the box and they are completely orange. No prior use, ordered right from the website. These concealers are not cheap so I can't tell you how disappointed i am. I used to swear by these concealers!! For reference, I am the palest white girl and ordered shade 1 and it's 100% orange, see photo.
Customer review from Benefit Cosmetics en_US
New formula?
I absolutely LOVED the first bottle of this I had. The coverage was flawless, and it wore so well on my skin. However, when I went to buy again, it came in and it looks very discoloured…almost like it is old and started to separate? Super iffy on using it
Recommends this product
Customer review from Benefit Cosmetics en_US
Boiing
Great product. Please do not discontinue Could bring down cost
Benefit products are the Best, hands down
This is a great product. It really covers up. Doesn't make my 40s-something "mature" skin look older. It wasn't easy finding my match of color tho and I wish they had a better way of doing that.
Recommends this product
Customer review from Benefit Cosmetics en_US
I can't figure out why but the color is off?
The color is off, It's the same color number (4) but very different from the one I have? The one I received has an orange tint to it.
Not same quality. Horrible, clearly.
I bought THREE of this product #3 Boi Ing Cakeless Concealer (a product that I have been using since they discontinued the stay, don't stray). I ordered this product January 14, 2026 and I had no need to open the product until my old Boi Ing product was emptied. I opened the product and noticed a very strange orange discoloration of the tube and thought that was weird so I opened the other two brand new products and they all had the same discoloration. I have always recommended and stood behind benefit cosmetic products so I've never felt the need to have to open up all of my products when I get them to check for quality. I contacted benefit and they said since it's past the 30 days they can't do anything for me! judging by other reviews of the same exact product, I have seen online and on this Benefit page that this is a clearly a quality issue. I've been a customer for 25+ years. Extremely disappointed they aren't standing behind their product when clearly there is an issue.
Customer review from Benefit Cosmetics en_US