I ordered these earrings in both the silver and gold. They are slightly smaller than I thought, but that didn't affect my rating. The only reason I knocked a star off was because both pictures made the earrings appear to have a brushed finish on the outside and shiny on inside - they do not, just standard shiny finish everywhere. All in all nice everyday earrings and purchased on sale so I will keep them. They go with everything. But I hope Macy's would change out the photos on the product to represent it accurately.