I don't know if it is the formulation or the brush or both. I had to remove lots of mascara from the brush before applying and it was still very goopy. The brush did not separate the lashes very well. It always look at the brush style before buying any mascara because that is the "make or break" deal I am looking for. I usually like curved brushes but I think this one is not a true bristle type. I think it is a rubbery type. Those never work for me. I am going to try a different brush with the formula to see if that helps. I do like the fact that is is non irritating to my eyes. Many, many mascaras are very irritating to my eyes. So that was a big plus. The brush needs to be improved.

Very, very clumpy mascara. I do not recommend this product.

I have small and delicate eyes so I always get stains of black mascara under my eyes, but this is the first one that stays and does not make a mess. Also, I don't feel the burn in my eyes I normally feel with other mascaras if I use them for a long time. And the removal is sooo easy that I use the brand Fresh for cleansing and everything comes off very easily.

I am shocked this mascara has any good reviews. It goes on so wet the lashes just stick together in huge clumps. I have to wipe off the brush several times so it’s dry enough to KIND OF separate the lash like a normal mascara. Not only not buying again but threw it in the trash.

It smudged not an all day wearable mascara for me. It clumped and didn’t look good.

For a long time I stayed loyal to a drugstore brand mascara and then I found Lune+Aster's Eclipse mascara and I will NEVER go back! This product lengthens, volumizes and curls my lashes like no other product I've used before. It provides the WOW factor every time. I also. love how easy it is to remove the product, the tubing effect is such a plus. I love this mascara so much and cannot wait to explore more of Lune+Aster's assortment.

Stays on your lashes, not shedding to make a dark circle under your eye

The application is not very convenient and the eyelashes at the end look like spider’s legs. But the main point is that (1) after using it just for the first time the mascara imprinted on the lower eyelid 2 hours after application. I cleaned that and then later in the evening it happened again (mascara as dust was under my lower eyelid). So it’s a big disappointment.