Great

I really like this eyeliner. It has stayed soft and hasn’t dried out. I just looked back at my orders and it is four years old. It is still working well, but I should toss it and buy a new one.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I've been using this liner for about a year now. It doesn't dry out as fast as the others and it does stay on all day for the most part. It is also very creamy and easier to apply!

I have worn eyeliners all my life, this came and no brush....not quite sure how to use it w/o a brush.

I use this as liner with an angled stiff brush and smudge or not, or as an overall shadow using my finger. You have to wash your hands after, yes, because the staying power is great. But it does wash off with a little soap and water, no problem, no rubbing. Highly recommended.

I purchased this item because I love the smokey eye look. I was happy with it for a few weeks, then it dried out and just became clumpy. The consistency wasn't as smooth as when I had it new. I wear it everyday and still had so much left but was unable to use the rest of it. This is my first gel eyeliner and I just hope they are not all like that.