Warriors Graphic Novel: The Prophecies Begin 1 by Erin Hunter
Product details
Web ID: 19875837A great adaptation to the original warriors series
The art in this is absolutely gorgeous, and the character designs fit the cats so well. This graphic novel condenses multiple books into one, so I would not recommend this to anyone who has not read the original series first. Lots of key character moments are rushed or not covered, but that is the nature of a comic adaptation such as this. For fans of the series however, you absolutely cannot go wrong with this comic. I recommend reading or rereading the original series right before going into the comic.
Recommends this product
Customer review from barnesandnoble.com
Bringing back memories
I got into Aaron Hunter in 2004 when she first published the first book of The warriors. And I have been collecting the book since then. I do like that some of the books are going into graphic novels or comic book style as for some people who have reading disabilities such as myself the comics bring you into a world of the written page with the series. Many can see the world of the warrior cats as I always called the series with a graphic novel even if they've read the book in paper. As for me there's no wrong way to read a story whether it be in the written book or as a graphic novel as both our stories. And with Aaron Hunter they have not just created one series but many series with the different animals and that's the best part of it but for me the cats will always be my favorite
Recommends this product
Customer review from barnesandnoble.com
Pretty good
I like the art but I think that this could have been better if we added the important events and not just remove them please
Recommends this product
Customer review from barnesandnoble.com
The artists should be fired.
The art is terrible compared to James.L.Barry. He was the previous artist who got fired, and these xats look like KITTYPETS. Also, the cats are fat, backgrounds are poorly drawn, the text and art is terrible, the faces are weird, etc.
Customer review from barnesandnoble.com
4.5 AMAZINGLY rushed From "Inexperience Reader"
Before I review, I would like to clarify that I first read the newer graphic novels before I read the actual books and then listen to the audiobooks. I hoped this would look more like the other graphic novels, but this is better. I loved the cover art on each side and the side of the book, and I think Yellowfang really fits the description of her character. Now I would like to say this, I feel like the whole book was a bit rushed. I know in the behind-the-scenes they said they picked only certain scenes from the OG book, but I feel like there wasn't enough emotion. I think they could have gone more into the relationships between Fireheart and Spottedleaf, Fireheart and Yellowfang, and Graystripe and Silverstream. I wanted to see every detail in a visual version of the book. I think if the book was double the length then there would have been room for more details in the story. or just make one book for ONE BOOK. But hey, still a great book, great series, can't wait for the next one.
Recommends this product
Customer review from barnesandnoble.com
Amazing book.
This book is amazing. Warriors cats has come a long way and it stills has long way still. Now we're even getting more magmas. Even though this an adaptation and it's bit different from the book it's still great.
Recommends this product
Customer review from barnesandnoble.com