I have used Benefit's They're Real! In Brown for years, but they stopped making it, and the black smudges too badly. Unfortunately, this also smudges by mid afternoon, so I am not a fan. The mascara itself is nice.

Amazing mascara! I love that it doesn’t clump or smudge. I have very fine lashes and this mascara is the best that I have used. Well worth the price.

I have oily skin, after an hour or so of application, this mascara smudges along the top of my eye socket and looks absolutely dreadful I don't wear it on my lower lashes but it still manages to leave a shadow below my lower lash line Not good

My sister picked up this mascara for me before my daughter's memorial. When I looked in the mirror after the event, and realized how stunning my lashes were (despite what the rest of my body through) I actually started to laugh. I mean, I really cried. At one point, I pressed my face into my husband's shirt and sobbed. His shirt, and my face were not smudged at all. Thanks for the best mascara on the market, and the moment of levity on one of the hardest days of my life!

I absolutely love this mascara, gives you length, volume!!!! and smudge free!!!!

Never have I used such a sticky and clumpy mascara. When removing due to the clumps and residue I was left with 15 eyelashes falling out leaving a gap on my eyelid - not the prettiest!! I am extremely disappointed in this product and the condition it has left my eyes in.

I love this mascara. It makes my lashes so so long. No other mascara has made my lashes look this good.

Seems as though the product was old, dey and clumpy.