Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil

4.5 (554)
$28.00
Size:Standard
5,871 customers purchased
Offers & perks
3x Star Rewards Points
See offer details

Product details

Web ID: 2808902
NOW available in 12 shades to flatter every hair color, anyone can be an expert with this super easy brow-filling and shaping eyebrow pencil! Benefit's goof proof brow pencil features a custom goof-proof tip that instantly shapes, defines & fills in brows. The soft, glide-on color creates naturally full, beautiful brows and the spoolie-brush effortlessly blends the 12-hour* waterproof** color.

  • Product Features

    • Beauty tip: To lock in the brow pencil's soft color for 24, budge-proof hours, apply the 24-HR Brow Setter Shaping & Setting Gel on top.
    • How to use:
    • Use the wide part of the custom tear-drop tip to shape & fill brows using a couple of strokes from the start to your arch to build color
    • Use the pointed edge of the tip to define the outer end of your brows
    • Blend with Spoolie-brush for full & natural-looking brows
    • SIZE 0.01 oz/ 0.34 g
    • *instrumental test on 20 panelists
    • **instrumental test on 22 panelists
    • Book a Benefit Browbar appointment near you

  • Shipping & Returns

    • This item qualifies for Free Shipping with minimum purchase! exclusions & details
    • This item may not be shipped to District of Columbia
    • Enjoy a longer window to return most of your holiday purchases. See our Extended Holiday Return Policy to see if this item qualifies.
    • California and Minnesota customers call 1-800-289-6229 for Free Shipping information.
    • For complete details, see our Shipping and Returns policies.
    • Please call customer service for returns.

Ratings & Reviews

4.5/5

554 star ratings, 398 reviews

Write a Review
79.4% of reviews have 5 stars
440
9.0% of reviews have 4 stars
50
3.6% of reviews have 3 stars
20
2.7% of reviews have 2 stars
15
5.2% of reviews have 1 star
29

On average, customers rate the Oil-absorbing/moisturizing of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Natural wear/long lasting of this item as Long lasting.

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Neutral.

8 customer images

  • Perfect for Platinum Blonde or Grey
  • £10 extra for a brush!
  • Shade 6, warm or cool?
  • Cute packaging and truly a "goof-proof" eyebrow pencil/brush combo
398 reviews
Sadie1
18 days ago
from WA

On average, customers rate the Natural wear/long lasting of this item as Long lasting.

Really Love This

Personally, this eyebrow pencil works for me. The older you get (you'll see, lol) you lose your eyebrows. This stays in place until you wash it off. I buy and stock up when it's 50% off. Best time to try something if you haven't to see if it is for you!

On average, customers rate the Natural wear/long lasting of this item as Long lasting.

Recommends this product

Diana
19 days ago
from AZ

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Bold.

Good eyebrow filler

Easy to apply

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Bold.

Recommends this product

37Zhang
21 days ago
from GA

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Bold.

The Perfect Brow Pencil!

I’ve been using these Eyebrow Pencil for years, and it’s truly the only brow product I trust. The color always looks so natural—never too harsh—and it blends seamlessly with my brows. The shape of the pencil makes it incredibly easy to fill in and define, even on days when I’m rushing. It gives me full, perfectly shaped brows in just a few strokes. Absolutely love it and can’t imagine my routine without it!

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Bold.

Recommends this product

NLF
23 days ago

Benefit Cosmetics- Goof Proof

I love Goof Proof and will be a return buyer.

Recommends this product

Michi
25 days ago

Customer service

Great help! Very pleasant and helpful service. Thank you!

Michelle
27 days ago

Not waterproof

I have been using this brand for over 5 years. Why I still don’t know. I’m now t good with makeup so makeup artis at Saphora always say use this one. I have extremely thin eyebrows. I just want a brow pencil not thin because I can’t draw, that is waterproof, and glides on without leaving gaps on my skin, and being able to see the brow is fake. This does none of those. I have all the brow pencils by this brand. It’s not waterproof whatsoever! I have to carry the pencil with me when I go anywhere.

Jen7
28 days ago
from NY

On average, customers rate the Oil-absorbing/moisturizing of this item as Moisturizing.

On average, customers rate the Natural wear/long lasting of this item as Long lasting.

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Bold.

Best Brow Pencil

This brow pencil is my favorite so far! The texture is spot on and the angled tip makes it goof proof! Easy to appy!

On average, customers rate the Oil-absorbing/moisturizing of this item as Moisturizing.

On average, customers rate the Natural wear/long lasting of this item as Long lasting.

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Bold.

Recommends this product

JB
30 days ago

Dior brow pencil

My first pencil I did not care for because the product did not glide on easily, I had to make a lot of strokes. I usually buy a soft black brow color but had tried grey brown for a change, maybe the color was too light so that is why I had a lot of strokes. It is just “ok”. I decided to order again with dark brown. I like the color better, less strokes but it still does not glide on easy like the discontinued Dior pencil which was super great.