Men's Pinch Prep Penny Loafer

4.2 (58)
$160.00
Color:Black Brushoff
Size: Please select

Product details

Web ID: 20739248
Alas, a slip-on as timeless as any lace-up: Cole Haan's Pinch Prep Penny Loafer, complete with a quintessential penny slot and made with their best, long-wearing leather.

  • Product Features

    • Rounded moc toe
    • Slip-on
    • Cushioned insole
    • Flexible and durable rubber sole
    • Brushoff leather finish; brand detailing on outsole, sockliner
    • Leather upper; leather, polyester lining; EVA footbed; rubber outsole
    • Imported

  • Shipping & Returns

    • California and Minnesota customers call 1-800-289-6229 for Free Shipping information.
    • Returns are accepted at any Macy's store within 30 days from purchase date. Last Act items are final sale and sold "as is." No returns, exchanges, or price adjustments allowed.
    • For complete details, see our Shipping and Returns policies.

Ratings & Reviews

Here's what customers think
  • Some customers found the shoes stylish and comfortable
  • Many customers experienced significant fit and comfort issues
  • Shoes were reported to run large and feel overly snug or narrow, even after ordering a size down
  • Some shoes caused blisters or were uncomfortable for extended wear
  • A few customers praised the shoes as sleek and soft
  • The negative feedback about the poor fit and comfort appears to outweigh the positive comments
AI-generated summary from 23 customers reviews.
4.2/5

58 star ratings, 23 reviews

Write a Review
70.7% of reviews have 5 stars
41
3.4% of reviews have 4 stars
2
5.2% of reviews have 3 stars
3
12.1% of reviews have 2 stars
7
8.6% of reviews have 1 star
5

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Neutral.

2 customer images

23 reviews
DAMON L
6 days ago
Verified PurchaserYes

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

CLASSIC

COMFORTABLE IS AN UNDERSTATEMENT AND MOST DEFINITELY A CLASSIC LOOK

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Recommends this product

Sofia
1 month ago
from Miami, FL
Verified PurchaserYes

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Great

Was recommended by worker, they’re great looking and comfortable

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Recommends this product

Majid
3 months ago
from Chicago
Verified PurchaserYes

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Old Money

First suedes in my collection dark brown leather fit perfect and looks stylish

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Recommends this product

Mesay
3 months ago

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

The shoes on sale

The shoes on sale now can I get back the different?

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Recommends this product

Cincybuyer
3 months ago
from Cincinnati
Verified PurchaserYes

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Not my typical experience with Cole Haan

Bought the brown nubuck leather version. Had to go down a size from my usual in this brand. After wearing for 8ish hours, they stretched out to now be too big. They’re also uncomfortable even after breaking in

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

A
3 months ago

Shoes

Very comfortable for the foot. They are a great fit and really look nice with a pants suit!

Michael
4 months ago
from New York cityy

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

performance

hi this is Michael the penny pinch poafer was 1/2 size too small for my foot except I'm already looking to purchase new pair for the new year bye see ya soon 2026 great comfortable shoe

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Yourfavuncle91
5 months ago
from New York, NY
Verified PurchaserYes

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Non recommend for long term

These shoes look amazing but they are not comfortable. I’m a size 12.5 so I got a 13.

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.