Good quality eye pencils in colours are hard to find. This one goes on smoothly, and stays in place. Nice choice of colours. Not everyone wants black eyeliner. I don't wear a lot of makeup - but like a little coloured liner, mascara, blush and lipstick. These are perfect!

I am a loyal Estée Lauder woman since 1979. From moisturizer, foundation, lipstick, blush, mascara, eyeshadow and eyeliner. The only time I used a different product was when they stopped selling hyacinth sky and I used a Doir product. I ordered the double wear eye pencil and ordered the pencil sharpener.I loved the eyeliner until it needed sharpening, snapped at end and wouldn't sharpen. Hollow inside with no pencil. Estée Lauder sharpener wouldn't sharpen I had to use my Dior one. The pencil is hollow on both pieces. Very disappointed...I don't know if this is a quality control issue and just a fluke. I took pictures if you would like to see the hollow pencil. I assume this isn't going to last to long. I only had for a week .

I really like eye liner.it is easy to apply and it stays for the whole day I am happy with the purchase

This is my stand by. If I wear nothing else I have this eyeliner on. It's easy to use and durable .

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Good staying power but able to be blended.

Smooth eyeliner but needs to be sharpened . Lasts all day!

My eyes are very sensitive and only few eyeliner goes well with them. I use eyeliner on my waterline and this eyeliner stays all day and doesn't bother my eyes. I got sapphire and in love with it, I'll be ordering black and coffee soon..

You really can't go wrong with this. I have no reason to switch to another brand. Very happy.