Men's Garner Penny Loafers

4.5 (34)
Sorry, this item is currently unavailable.
Shop Similar Items
Shop All Johnston & Murphy

Product details

Web ID: 3096343
Johnston & Murphy presents their take on a classic style with these Garner Penny loafers in fine leather.

  • Product Features

    • Moccasin toe
    • Slip-on style
    • Leather lining for comfort and durability
    • Leather upper; leather sole
    • Imported

  • Shipping & Returns

    • This item qualifies for Free Shipping with minimum purchase! exclusions & details
    • Our Normal Gift Boxing is not available for this item.
    • Returns are accepted at any Macy's store within 90 days from purchase date. Last Act clearance items must be returned within 30 days from purchase date.
    • For complete details, see our Shipping and Returns policies.

Ratings & Reviews

4.5/5

34 star ratings & reviews

Write a Review
73.5% of reviews have 5 stars
25
17.6% of reviews have 4 stars
6
2.9% of reviews have 3 stars
1
0.0% of reviews have 2 stars
0
5.9% of reviews have 1 star
2

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Neutral.

34 reviews
James R.
6 years ago

J&M’s Best Slip On

I have been purchasing J&M shoes for more than two decades, and this shoe is absolutely beautiful, comfortable, and stylish. The leather is subtle and the interior sheepskin lining — wonderful!

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

External reviewer
6 years ago

Uncomfortable in the fact that

Uncomfortable in the fact that they are narrow. However they run larger in length.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

External reviewer
6 years ago

Garner Penny

i did not like the fit at all so I returned the shoe. the shoe ran small from a width perspective and big from the length.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

External reviewer
6 years ago

Reasonably priced, stylish and comfortable.

Reasonably priced, stylish and comfortable. There was no downside to this purchase.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Joy W.
6 years ago

I am returning these shoes

I am returning these shoes that I purchased for my husband for Christmas. he loved his Anysworth Penny shoes, but could not get his foot into these.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Barbara F.
6 years ago

Great Surprise Christmas Gift

Great looking shoe, fits perfectly and was a great surprise Christmas gift from my wife.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

External reviewer
6 years ago

Great choice

I needed to upgrade both my black and brown loafers and chose the Garner Penny's. Great fit, style and comfort so I'm very happy with my selection. Most J&M shoes run a size smaller than I'm used to with other shoes so I chose the 8M's instead of the 8 1/2 M's and they fit great.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Douglas K.
6 years ago

Unhappy customer

Bought this shoe back in August. Wore it like 10 times and the heel came off. Called Johnston & Murphy to complain and they sent me a new pair free of charge. Wore the second pair about 6 times and the heel fell off again. Not sure what the problem is but I am very disappointed. A nice looking shoe nonetheless but if the heel can't stay on, then it's not good quality.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy