Men's Holcomb Plain Toe Oxfords
This item is unavailable

Men's Holcomb Plain Toe Oxfords

Still curious? Here’s a closer look

Men's Holcomb Plain Toe Oxfords

Product details

Web ID: 17505052

Practicality meets sophistication with this handsome water-resistant oxford.

  • Product Features

    • Full grain water-resistant leather upper
    • Soft leather and textile linings
    • Water-resistant construction for protection from the elements
    • Removable, cushioned footbed with leather and textile covering
    • Durable rubber outsole
    • This item purchased online must be returned to the vendor by mail only. This item cannot be returned to Macy's stores.
    • Upper - Full Grain Leather, Lining - Leather, Outsole - Rubber
    • Spot Clean
    • Imported

  • Shipping & Returns

    • This item qualifies for Free Shipping with minimum purchase! exclusions & details
    • Our Normal Gift Boxing is not available for this item.
    • This item purchased online must be returned to the vendor by mail only. This item cannot be returned to Macy's stores.
    • California and Minnesota customers call 1-800-289-6229 for Free Shipping information.
    • For complete details, see our Shipping and Returns policies.

Ratings & Reviews

Here's what customers think
  • The shoes are widely praised for their exceptional comfort, with a cushioned sole and flexible construction allowing all-day wear without foot pain.
  • They are described as well-made with high-quality craftsmanship and materials, featuring a timeless, stylish design.
  • While a few reviewers noted sizing issues or durability concerns, the vast majority of customers are highly satisfied with the comfort, quality, and versatility of the product.
AI-generated summary from 36 customers reviews.
4.7/5

44 star ratings, 36 reviews

Write a Review
36
4
3
0
1

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

4 customer images

36 reviewssorted by Newest

Jac
11 months ago

Great shoe!

Amazing fit! True to size, looks great with every pant color.

Recommends this product

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

External reviewer
11 months ago

Heel ret support

I tried two types of shoes and in both I found it impossible to feel as comfortable as with those that have a heel rest support and I would like them to continue manufacturing them.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

BT
11 months ago

Comfortable and quality

A nice shoe. Good comfort and quality materials. A tad heavy .

Recommends this product

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

William
1 year ago

Just simply exquisite

I couldn’t be more impressed with my Johnston & Murphy dress shoes. From the moment I unboxed them, the craftsmanship was obvious—premium leather, elegant stitching, and a sleek silhouette that instantly elevates any outfit. What truly stands out is the comfort. These shoes required almost no break-in period. The footbed offers excellent support, and even after a full day on my feet, they still feel great. Whether I'm at the office, a formal event, or just dressing sharp for a night out, these shoes deliver on both style and practicality. I’ve received several compliments, and people are always surprised when I say they’re not custom-made—because that’s how they feel. Johnston & Murphy has nailed the balance of timeless design and modern comfort. Highly recommended for anyone who values quality and wants a shoe that looks as good as it performs.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Beatriz
1 year ago

Nice shoes, my husband loves them.

I recently purchased a pair of waterproof Johnston & Murphy shoes for my husband, and we are both extremely impressed with the quality and style. The craftsmanship is top-notch — from the stitching to the leather finish, everything looks and feels premium. He mentioned how comfortable they were right out of the box, with no break-in period needed, which is rare for dress shoes. They’re versatile enough to wear with both professional and more casual outfits, and he’s already received several compliments. These shoes strike a great balance between timeless design and everyday wearability. I highly recommend Johnston & Murphy for anyone looking for durable, stylish footwear that doesn’t compromise on comfort.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Michael
1 year ago

A Stead Everyday Dress Shoe

A perfect combination of fit and comfort. Appearance holds up very well, even under everyday wear and tear over an extended period of time. 10/10.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Rubi
1 year ago

Fantastic quality

My son loved the shoes! He said it’s very comfortable and stylish.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Katrina
1 year ago

Great shoes

Excited to wear these in the winter, seem like they will work nicely in ice and snow.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy