I really am satisfied with the Tin Can Alley Dinner plates that I have. I purchased a dozen when I replaced my old dinner plates and they are just beautiful..

Beautiful plate

Different material than original plate. The original is bone China and this is porcelain. Not much of a difference, but they do feel differently.

Quality control is not what it used to be. Some defects on all plates. Inconsistent production. Appears to be seconds, not first quality any more.

My sister has these dishes. I ordered a few because they were on sale. I absolutely love them. The salad plates are a perfect size, and I love the dinner plates too! I will order more when they go on sale again! Love that they are so versatile!

I shopped around and looked at many options before purchasing these plates. I have a full set. This dinnerware is described as "casual fine bone china." I use them for everyday. They are very rich looking, and I combine them with various accent salad plates depending on the occasion or holiday. Love them.

Bought these as a wedding gift from a registry. They are beautiful and Macy's is always a great and super easy place to buy wedding presents!

I bought something similar but different that actually ended up costing more and hated them so I went back to my original want. No regrets - I have the whole set with service for 10. While some of the dishes did get broken in transit, Macy's was quick to send replacements.