Eye Pencil

4.2 (32)
Sorry, this item is currently unavailable.
Shop Similar Items
Shop All MAC
Have a question or need advice? Call one of our beauty pros at 1-800-247-3520.

Product details

Web ID: 106343
Eye Pencils are formulated to provide rich, consistent colour using ingredients that have virtually no irritancy potential. They are comfortable to apply and sharpen to a fine point to allow for a precise application. Eye Pencils can be used to create a sharp line or a softer, smoky effect. They are long-lasting and won't cake or streak.

  • Product Features

    • MAC is working toward a cruelty-free world. MAC does not test on animals & never asks others to test on their behalf. MAC advocates for ending animal testing globally & is taking steps toward that goal every day.

  • Shipping & Returns

    • This item qualifies for Free Shipping with minimum purchase! exclusions & details
    • Our Normal Gift Boxing is not available for this item.
    • For complete details, see our Shipping and Returns policies.

Ratings & Reviews

Here's what customers think
  • MAC eyeliners are generally well-received by customers
  • Customers praise the smooth application, long-lasting wear, and wide color selection of the eyeliners
  • Many find the eyeliner pencils to be high-quality, pigmented, and easy to use
  • The most common positive feedback is on the eyeliners' staying power, as they do not smudge or fade throughout the day
  • However, a few reviewers were disappointed, finding that the eyeliners smudged or faded quickly, especially in hot and humid conditions
  • Some felt the eyeliners were not as bold as expected
  • A couple mentioned difficulty in achieving ultra-thin lines due to the soft texture of the eyeliners
AI-generated summary from 32 customers reviews.
4.2/5

32 star ratings & reviews

Write a Review
46.9% of reviews have 5 stars
15
34.4% of reviews have 4 stars
11
9.4% of reviews have 3 stars
3
6.3% of reviews have 2 stars
2
3.1% of reviews have 1 star
1

On average, customers rate the Oil-absorbing/moisturizing of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Natural wear/long lasting of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Neutral.

32 reviews
Pippa
2 years ago

Disappointed

I haven't bought from MAC before. Assistant kind and chose eye pencil in the colour 'coffee' for me. (She didn't mention it wasn't waterproof or tell me they have a waterproof eye pencil which I would have preferred). This particularly eye pencil fades quickly and smudges. No use to me as I am constantly checking it hasn't smudged onto my under eye. Very disappointed and will return item.

Customer review from Mac UK

barbydoll
3 years ago

It works for me!

As an 84years young lady I find Mac coffee pencil is perfect for outlining my eyes without looking too harsh or heavy.

Customer review from Mac UK

thesmiley
7 years ago

Not my thing

Yeah not really sure if this one worth the expensive price tag. I was sold on it by my beautician and to be honest, I still find that it smudges everywhere and I'm not seeing the results that other people have. I think it is not black and flash enough and that I could have bought the similar quality pencil from a cheaper brand. But that's just my personal experience and it could be different for others.

Customer review from BeautyHeaven

Donna
9 years ago
from West Covina, California
What is your make-up style?Natural
Where did you purchase this item?Online
Did you read product reviews online before purchasing this item?No
Is this the first time you purchased this product?No
What is your eye color?Brown
What is your gender?Female
How often do you shop at macys.com?Occasionally
What is your skin tone?Medium
What is your skin type?Oily
What is your age?50-60

On average, customers rate the Oil-absorbing/moisturizing of this item as Moisturizing.

On average, customers rate the Natural wear/long lasting of this item as Long lasting.

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Bold.

Love MAC Eye Pencils

I love this MAC Eye Pencil. I got the coffee color because it goes so well with my features. I have medium toned skin and dark brown eyes and dark brown hair. The pencil doesn't smear (even though I have oily skin) and lasts all day long.

On average, customers rate the Oil-absorbing/moisturizing of this item as Moisturizing.

On average, customers rate the Natural wear/long lasting of this item as Long lasting.

On average, customers rate the Sheer/bold of this item as Bold.

Mary
9 years ago

One of the better

No smudge pencil, the color is a lighter black, not a dark kohl

pittsburghgirl1801
10 years ago
What is your gender?Female
What is your age?30-39
How often do you shop at macys.com?Occasionally

No thanks!

Did not like this at all - super smudgy and ran all over my face. Returned. Try the modern twist kajal by mac instead!

Celticwave
10 years ago

Terrific

Love all Mac makeup works great lasts for hours!!!

subhanalla
10 years ago

Great product.

Smooth and easy to use. Love the liner and quick to use.