I love the way the liner looks. Easy to apply precisely. Here’s my dilemma- I cannot get the liner to come out of the tube- it doesn’t turn. I got the bottom cover off and still nothing. I’d love for someone to tell me how to work this liner.

TERRIBLE COLOR. TO DARK AND THE PENCIL IS VERY THIN TO PUT ON LIPS. SHOULDN'T HVE BOUGHT 3

great for the money

Creamy formula, not drying. Easy to use, doesnt bleed! Great quality for price

Disappointed. Since a long time popular drug store brand makeup company went out of business that had amazing lipliners, I have been looking for a good retractable lip liner. They are very hard to find for some reason and I was so excited to find it. Finally. The actual product. Not so good. I wanted brown so I tried both. One was Sand Beige and it was way too light and the other, don't have the color handy, was way too dark or strong. Sienna maybe? No in between. The crayon breaks easily and I found that it got cold too. Odd so it broke I guess. I do not live in a freezing cold climate but I keep my makeup in my bag. Wish the lightest brown was maybe a little darker or deeper. It was close but just does not cut it.

Easy to use! Matches the black suede lipstick wonderfully.

I really miss Cocoa lipliner. I don't find any of the others simular to that color. Why was it discontinued ?

After having use many other lip liners, NYX is definitely my very favorite. It goes on well and lasts a very long time.