Do not buy
Ughh I hate leaving ugly reviews but , this is oberhyped
Customer review from NYX Professional Makeup
Response from NYX Professional Makeup
Hi there! Thank you for trying our Suede Matte Lip Liner. We are sorry to hear it didn't live up to the hype for you! We always want our products to feel like a holy grail, so your feedback is super important and has been shared with our team as we work to level up our collection. We hope you find a new favorite with us soon!
Great Product!
So smooth and long lasting! The brown color I've been looking for forever.
Recommends this product
Customer review from NYX Professional Makeup
Something has changed...
Something has changed in the manufacturing of these pencils--in the last year I've thrown out all 3 (brown and medium brown) that I've purchased because they are now hard/dry and downright painful to use, deposit little color, and the crayon shatters so much when I attempt to sharpen them that they just can't be salvaged. It's so disappointing because they used to be creamy and a dependable go-to. I see that my old nubs of this pencil were made in Germany and now the new ones are made in Mexico. NYX, any chance of going back to your previous manufacturer?? I need to find a new brand.
Customer review from NYX Professional Makeup
Response from NYX Professional Makeup
Hey! Thank you for sharing your feedback on our Slim Eye Pencil. We’re truly sorry to hear your recent experience didn't meet the creamy, dependable standard you’ve loved for years. While we strive to maintain the quality of our products even when minor formula changes occur, we want to assure you that the L'Oréal Group is committed to the highest safety and quality standards across all 40 of our global factories, where every ingredient is thoroughly reviewed by our internal safety team. We’ve shared your concerns regarding the texture and sharpening with our team for future consideration, and we encourage you to check the ingredient list on our website or the product itself for the most up-to-date information. If you're still having issues, please give us a ring at 844-335-3510 and mention case number 45005559 so we can assist you. Our team is here Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM ET.
Mine was hard
I've always been a fan of NYX but this isn't my favorite product from them. It is very dry and hard to line the lips. I'm unsure if I got a bad one or if they are all the same. I tried sharpening it and it was brittle. The color is cute once you get it on and it lasts. Just wish the formula was smoother.
Customer review from influenster.com
Response from influenster.com
Hey! Thank you for sharing your feedback on our Suede Matte Lip Liner. We're so glad you loved the color and its lasting power, but we are sorry to hear about your experience with the texture. This definitely doesn't sound like the smooth application we aim for! We've passed your comments along to our team for further review. We invite you to explore our Line Loud Vegan Longwear Lip Liner for an ultra-creamy, smooth-glide experience that we think you'll absolutely adore!
Totally AWESOME
I LOVE LOVE LOVE my thin eyeliner pencils. I bought 3 & they just glide right on. My fav is sapphire so I bought 2 of those and 1 sparkly black !!!
Customer review from NYX Professional Makeup
this color is perfect
this color is exactly a dark version of the color of my lips. it is a rather dry pencil and i would love to see it in the retractable version, but i wear it every day! it is a perfect neutral...
Customer review from NYX Professional Makeup
Good for the price
I have this lip liner in the color “vintage” and it’s a really pretty dark raspberry color. The only downside is I have to reapply throughout the day. But for the price it really gets the job done and it’s really pigmented.
Customer review from influenster.com
Used to be good pencils
Used to be my favorite eyeliner. Couldn’t find it in stores for a long time, then finally came across it being sold online! I was so excited and bought like 20 pencils because it was my favorite. These pencils have been awful with my most current purchase. Every time I try to sharpen, the pencil tip beaks off. I’ve wasted several pencils just trying to get one sharpened. It’s not the sharpener either, I’ve bought three different brands. So disappointed
Customer review from NYX Professional Makeup
Response from NYX Professional Makeup
Hey! We're sorry to hear about your Slim Eye Pencil. Please give us a call at 844-335-3510 with case number 45105066 so we can assist you. Our team is here Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM ET. Talk soon!