to start, i’m gen-z, and pretty experienced as far as eyeliner goes. i could have the worst experience and still get over it. but a “bad experience” with this eyeliner is a joke of an explanation. i’ve tried serval drug store eyeliners and this is the worst yet. if you want and eyeliner you will use twice then discard, this is the one for you. the very tip dries out after two uses, making it extremely difficult to use. the entire tip falls out. the material leaks out of the tube. the material takes about 5 solid minutes to completely dry, which tends to be very inconvenient to the majority of people. it smudges and comes off very easily. today was my breaking point as i was getting ready and the tip was not producing material, the tip again, falls off the tube, and the material leaks all over my sink, my hands, ect. though i have washed my hands twice, i am still covered in product. as i finish best i can i check my car mirror and what do you know. my upper eyelids have product on them from the eyeliner not setting within a reasonable amount of time. it smudged all over my eyelid and took an unreasonable amount of time to fix. so yeah. cant say i recommend.