This mascara does not rub off when my eyes water. It works very well and makes my lashes long and beautiful. It does not clump or flake. It is easy to get off with makeup remover. I have tried dozens of waterproof mascaras. This one is a keeper.

I tried the new NYX Hype and is smudges. By the end of the day, I look like a raccoon. I have wore NYX Doll Eye mascara for years and I miss it. Please bring it back. I have wasted so much money on different mascaras.

Great coverage, highly pigmented. My eyelashes are pretty short & fine, but this mascara makes it look like I actually have some fuller lashes. Only downside is it seems to bleed a little. Not sure if this is due to my oily skin/sweat, or if i’m not giving it enough time to dry before heading out & about.

It's waterproof, so that's nice, but it doesn't give you as much volume as they say it does. If you're looking for mascara purely based on volume, I'd recommend that you try something else.

Pros: -easy to remove Cons: -brush too big for tiny lashes -isn’t waterproof enough in high humidity, beach, for swimming, rain, etc.

This mascara is amazingly light. The brush grabs every lash. No clumping. Water proof. I've bought other mascaras that clump and are heavy but this mascara is the only one that doesn't irritate my eyes and washes off easily.

I never got mine in the mail, at least I got refunded

This was the most clumpy mascara I've ever used. I do not recommend.