Icarus is very durable and weighted well. I have had the set since 2019 and it's 2021. However, I agree that the dinner spoons are too large for some family members. However, the design is so classic, and fits well with our moderne/mid-century, our art deco and our coastal decor. I hope that Oneida upgrades the set, replacing the dinner spoons with slightly smaller versions and calling the existing dinner spoons something else. It would be unfortunate to abandon such an excellent, classic and functional pattern that goes great for casual or special occasion dining.

sizing is terrible -- big spoons are like serving spoons and teaspoons are tiny. Retutning

I have to admit to being a bit of a silverware snob. It has to be properly weighted and feel good to touch. This set meets both needs and I looks good too!

This is a Christmas present so I have not seen or used them BUT since my son asked for this Oneida table service they must be good as he is very picky.

The sizes of the utensils included in this set are whimsical. The dinner spoon is a serving spoon. The teaspoon and small fork are like something you would find in a child's play kitchen. Not meant for a grown up dinner table. I was drawn by the simplicity of the design and the Oneida name, but Oneida should be embarassed by the lack of utility in design of this set. A real shame.

I bought this set as an upgrade to a cheap set we have had for a while, and while I really love how it looks and feels, the larger forks and regular spoons that come with this set are absolutely ridiculously sized. Buddy the Elf would refer to them as "ginormous", bordering on hilarious. There's no way I can get the whole spoon in my mouth, so we utilize the regular spoons as serving spoons (yes they really are that big!). For myself and my kids we stick to using the teaspoons and salad forks for regular use. Larger humans will be fine to use the rest.

Very disappointed in this set. We got it for our wedding about 6 months ago, and I was so excited. Sadly, it did not live up to expectations. Within a few weeks, pieces started rusting! I made sure to carefully follow all care instructions, but it didn't matter. This did not live up to the quality standards I thought Oneida stood for. Do not recommend if you want lasting silverware.

Very nice looking, solid. Too wide to fit in the individual slots in my dish washer basket. The table spoons are huge! Be prepared.