Men's Gibbons Cap Toe Oxfords

4.3 (33)
$139.00
Color:Mahogany
Size: Please select

Width: Please select

Tiles

Product details

Web ID: 17505053
This classic oxford in full-grain leather is paired with an exclusive TRUFOAM footbed for ultra-cushioned comfort.

  • Product Features

    • Full grain leather upper
    • Soft, leather and textile lining
    • Highly cushioned, molded and removable TRUFOAM footbed for ultra-light rebound comfort
    • Leather and textile covered footbed
    • Durable rubber outsole
    • This item purchased online must be returned to the vendor by mail only. This item cannot be returned to Macy's stores.
    • Upper - Full Grain Leather, Lining - Leather, Outsole - Rubber
    • Spot Clean
    • Imported

  • Shipping & Returns

    • This item may not be shipped to Armed Forces Europe, Marshall Islands, Puerto Rico, Northern Mariana, Palau, Armed Forces Americas, Federated States of Micronesia, Guam, Armed Forces Pacific, Hawaii, U.S. Virgin Islands, Alaska, American Samoa
    • This item purchased online must be returned to the vendor by mail only. This item cannot be returned to Macy's stores.
    • California and Minnesota customers call 1-800-289-6229 for Free Shipping information.
    • For complete details, see our Shipping and Returns policies.
  • Have questions?
    Call or chat, our experts are here to help.
    1-800-BUY-MACY

Complete the look

Ratings & Reviews

Here's what customers think
  • The Johnston & Murphy dress shoes are generally well-received, with many customers praising their comfort, style, and value.
  • Positive reviews highlight the sophisticated look, great fit, and ability to be worn for long hours.
  • However, a minority of customers have reported issues with the shoes' durability and comfort, such as the soles coming apart or the leather scuffing easily.
  • Overall, the shoes seem to be a solid choice, offering a comfortable and stylish option, but the brand may need to address concerns about long-term quality and fit for certain customers.
AI-generated summary from 21 customers reviews.
4.3/5

33 star ratings, 21 reviews

Write a Review
75.8% of reviews have 5 stars
25
3.0% of reviews have 4 stars
1
6.1% of reviews have 3 stars
2
6.1% of reviews have 2 stars
2
9.1% of reviews have 1 star
3

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Neutral.

4 customer images

21 reviews
Kenny
29 days ago
from Chicago, IL USA
Verified PurchaserYes

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs small.

Great shoe

This is my second pair of this style. It's my favorite work shoe. The TruFoam inside is perfect for anyone who needs to stand for long periods of time. I also like the rubber sole as it feels safer than the Italian leather sole for winter wear. The capped toe gives it smart styling. The leather is a bit stiff to start but nothing that can't be fixed with a shoe stretcher.

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs wide.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs small.

Recommends this product

Helpful?
Gernestoc
4 months ago

Terrible quality

I bought these shoes in August of last year. They fit perfectly and are very comfortable, but unfortunately the quality is terrible. About six months after I started wearing them, the sole started to come apart. That’s when I realized it isn’t actually stitched—the thread that is supposed to join the sole is completely fake, and instead the glue used is of disastrous quality. I’ve tried to glue them back in several ways, but the result has not been satisfactory. During the process the bonding ends up uneven and stained with adhesive. The sad thing is that they keep coming apart to the point of becoming unusable. I live out of the USA so returning them wasn’t an easy option. I am very disappointed with this product and would not recommend the dress shoe line to anyone.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Bandit
4 months ago
from Florida
Verified PurchaserYes

Good

Good shoe

Recommends this product

Helpful?
Nick
9 months ago

Surprisingly disappointing

I only ever wear Johnston and Murphy for my dress shoes. My old ones needed replacing after wearing them everyday for 2 years due to scuff marks that weren’t savable. These shoes had a nicer looking insole and appeared classy like the rest of the J&Ms I’ve had, but the outside material seems cheaper and firmer than needed. They have not gotten much better after wearing them for 3 weeks. Almost too stiff to enjoy.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Jc
9 months ago

Dresser dress shoes

Got these for an upcoming wedding, great fit, great value! No break in time needed, service out of this world!

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Alireza
9 months ago

Great dress shoe

One of the best dress shoes I have ever had. It comfortable and stylish concurrents.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Dillon S
9 months ago
from Los Angeles, CA
Verified PurchaserYes

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs narrow.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Uncomfortable and easily scratch

Good looking shoes, but they are super uncomfortable and cut up the back of my heel every time I’ve worn them. They also scratch pretty easily and it seems like they are coated in a darker black, so it is really obvious when they are scratched.

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Runs narrow.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Runs large.

Helpful?
Vernon
12 months ago

Great shoes. I have always

Great shoes. I have always been a fan of Johnston and murphy. These didn't disappoint.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy