Men's Hayes Penny Slip-On Loafers

4.1 (42)
$129.90
Color:Burgundy Polished Full Grain
Size: Please select

Width: Please select

Tiles

Product details

Web ID: 15819971
Crafted of premium leather with a brush-off finish that enhances tonal shading and shine.

  • Product Features

    • Shoe width - medium and wide
    • Hand sewn construction
    • Combination heel
    • This item purchased online must be returned to the vendor by mail only. This item cannot be returned to Macy's stores.
    • Upper - Genuine Leather, Lining - Genuine Leather, Outsole - Rubber
    • Spot Clean
    • Imported

  • Shipping & Returns

    • This item may not be shipped to Northern Mariana, Federated States of Micronesia, Puerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands, Armed Forces Pacific, Armed Forces Americas, Armed Forces Europe, Hawaii, Palau, Guam, American Samoa, Marshall Islands, Alaska
    • This item purchased online must be returned to the vendor by mail only. This item cannot be returned to Macy's stores.
    • California and Minnesota customers call 1-800-289-6229 for Free Shipping information.
    • For complete details, see our Shipping and Returns policies.
    • Please call customer service for returns.

Ratings & Reviews

Here's what customers think
  • The penny loafers are generally well-received for their classic style, comfort, and durability.
  • Many customers find the shoes to be elegant and suitable for both casual and formal wear.
  • However, some customers have experienced issues with the fit, noting that the shoes tend to run large and can feel loose, especially around the heel.
  • A few reviewers also reported quality problems, such as the sole coming apart or the shoes developing an annoying squeak over time.
  • Overall, the majority of customers seem satisfied with the product's great value, comfort, and timeless appeal.
AI-generated summary from 38 customers reviews.
4.1/5

42 star ratings, 38 reviews

Write a Review
57.1% of reviews have 5 stars
24
23.8% of reviews have 4 stars
10
2.4% of reviews have 3 stars
1
9.5% of reviews have 2 stars
4
7.1% of reviews have 1 star
3

On average, customers rate the Runs narrow/runs wide of this item as Neutral.

On average, customers rate the Runs small/runs large of this item as Neutral.

2 customer images

38 reviews
External reviewer
2 months ago

My Father swore by this brand.

I really like the leather shoe. I've only worn them once so far. I had my shoe guy put some nylon taps on the heels as I am particularly hard on the left one since I am prior service. Too many days marching I guess. The length of the shoe is great, I wear a 13. Fit is good and width is average. They might be a little loose in the heels, but, if so I will put a pair of heel pads in them. I put my first coat of polish on them. The leather really takes the polish well and it won't be long before they have a good spit shine(like glass) all over.

Recommends this product

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Noah B
4 months ago

Looks great, terrible quality. ZERO durability.

Terrible quality loafer. Most money I've spent on shoes and they did not last a year before completely falling apart.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Don
5 months ago

too big

ordered my regular size but was too big. Returned for size smaller and same issue.Not worth the purchase

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Herman
7 months ago
from Cape Town South Africa

Best value for money classic durable footwear.

I have 3 pairs of J& M penny loafers that I have had for approximately 10 to 15 years now. They have all been resolved,have retained their shape and are still neat and sharp to wear. I also have a pair of lace up toe cap formal shoes in black that are over 20 years old and still beautiful and going strong. I live in South Africa. Great products from a great company.Thank you Johnstone and Murphy.

Recommends this product

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Michael
10 months ago

J & M penny loafers

The shoes are nice, good quality and comfortable. They run a little big. Loose in the heel. I would say it’s moderately loose. Mine squeak a little. Hope this clears up when they are broken in a little, it’s not really bad. I like them very much.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Molly
10 months ago

Love these loafers

Well made and classic! They take a little time to break in but Very comfortable. Please keep making these!!

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Patrick
10 months ago

Loafer

Great shoe, confortable, stylist Recommeded shoe to son

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy

Daniel
11 months ago

Dan

Nice. Great fit. Comfortable feel. I brought a black pair and several months later brought the other color.

Customer review from Johnston & Murphy