Skip to main content
Sign up for emails & get extra 25% off! Exclusions apply. Sign Up
Free Shipping with $25 purchase or fast & free Store Pickup. Exclusions

Cream Eyeshadow

Enjoy the flawless look of cream eyeshadow. Whether you want a simple pop of allover color or love the drama of a smokey eye, we’ve got creamy shadows from singles and palettes to sticks and tubes from your favorite beauty brands. Stock up on neutral tones and color your world with eye-catching shimmers and brights.

Subtle or Smoked Out
Keeping it fresh-faced? Try soft hues with a slight shimmer for a subtle look. Check out Benefit and Bare Escentuals bareMinerals for velvety shadows with longwearing formulas. Want to look sultry while out at night? Turn to smokey shadows including grey, black, and brown tones. Going glam for a special occasion? Accent a blue evening dress with dark blue color or highlight green eyes with purple shadow. Find the perfect palettes from Bobbi Brown, Smashbox and Laura Geller to create a dramatic look.

Complete the Look

For an even application, apply your favorite cream shadows with an eye shadow brush. Glide color over the eyelid to evenly transition to the brow. In a pinch? Cream shadow sticks are your best friends. Check out our bestselling long-wear formulas from in beautiful metallic tones and ultra-pigmented colors from Bobbi Brown and Laura Mercier. Create the look you want for day or night with essential eye makeup from Macy’s.

Show more
How to Pick up Your Order Curbside:
  • Available at limited stores. Click on the store location link to see which stores are Curbside Pickup eligible.
  • Once an order is made through Curbside Pickup, look for an email with specific instructions and pickup location for your store.
  • Orders that are placed before noon will be available for same day pickup. Orders made after 12pm will be available for pick up the next business day.