Free Shipping with $49 purchase + Free Store Pickup. Contiguous US. Exclusions
Macy's Presents: The Edit- A curated mix of fashion and inspiration Check It Out
ADS FROM UNAFFILIATED SITES

Cream Eyeshadow

Enjoy the flawless look of cream eyeshadow. Whether you want a simple pop of allover color or love the drama of a smokey eye, we’ve got creamy shadows from singles and palettes to sticks and tubes from your favorite beauty brands. Stock up on neutral tones and color your world with eye-catching shimmers and brights.

Subtle or Smoked Out
Keeping it fresh-faced? Try soft hues with a slight shimmer for a subtle look. Check out Benefit and Bare Escentuals bareMinerals for velvety shadows with longwearing formulas. Want to look sultry while out at night? Turn to smokey shadows including grey, black, and brown tones. Going glam for a special occasion? Accent a blue evening dress with dark blue color or highlight green eyes with purple shadow. Find the perfect palettes from Bobbi Brown, Smashbox and Laura Geller to create a dramatic look.

Complete the Look

For an even application, apply your favorite cream shadows with an eye shadow brush. Glide color over the eyelid to evenly transition to the brow. In a pinch? Cream shadow sticks are your best friends. Check out our bestselling long-wear formulas from in beautiful metallic tones and ultra-pigmented colors from Bobbi Brown and Laura Mercier. Create the look you want for day or night with essential eye makeup from Macy’s.

more
  • 48 items in Cream Eyeshadow

    • Filter
    • Sort By
    • All Items (48)
    • Free Pick Up
    • Sort by
    • 3 colors
      Clinique Touch Base for Eyes, .03oz
      $17.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free skincare duo with $55 Clinique purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (321)
    • 7 colors
      MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot, 0.17 oz
      $22.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (338)
    • 12 colors
      Urban Decay Moondust Eyeshadow
      $21.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      FREE 3pc makeup gift w/ $50 Urban Decay purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (686)
    • NEW! Anastasia Beverly Hills Dream Glow Kit
      $45.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (2)
    • 9 colors
      Clinique Chubby Stick Shadow Tint for Eyes
      $17.50
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free skincare duo with $55 Clinique purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (291)
    • 9 colors
      Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Sparkle Stick
      $30.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free makeup gift with $50 Bobbi Brown purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (8)
    • Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place EyeShadow Base,
      $21.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 3 pc skincare gift with $75 Lauder purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (221)
    • Estée Lauder 3-Pc. Bronze Beauty Sunlit Nudes Eye Set
      A $52.00 value
      Only $32.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 3 pc skincare gift with $75 Lauder purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (1)
    • 10 colors
      bareMinerals 5-in-1 BB Advanced Performance Cream Eyeshadow Broad Spectrum SPF 15, 0.1 oz
      $19.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 2pc Makeup gift w/ $35 bareMinerals purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (272)
    • 10 colors
      Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick, 0.05 oz
      $30.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free makeup gift with $50 Bobbi Brown purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (403)
    • 18 colors
      Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Colour, 0.05 oz
      $29.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Makeup Gift w/ $50 Laura Mercier Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (375)
    • Too Faced Natural Eyes Neutral Eye Shadow Palette
      $38.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      FREE makeup packette w/ Too Faced purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (6)
    • 10 colors
      Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Shadow, 0.12 oz
      $30.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free makeup gift with $50 Bobbi Brown purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (1208)
    • Estée Lauder 3-Pc. Romantic Beauty Extreme Smoky Eye Set
      A $52.00 value
      Only $32.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 3 pc skincare gift with $75 Lauder purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (4)
    • 9 colors
    • Urban Decay Naked2 Eyeshadow Palette
      $54.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      FREE 3pc makeup gift w/ $50 Urban Decay purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (4862)
    • 15 colors
      Lancôme Ombre Hypnôse Stylo Eyeshadow Stick
      $25.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Complimentary Makeup Gift w/ $50 Lancôme Purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (38)
    • Estée Lauder 3-Pc. Playful Beauty Sweet Pinks Eye Set
      A $52.00 value
      Only $32.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 3 pc skincare gift with $75 Lauder purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (4)
    • 5 colors
      Tarte Chrome Paint Shadow Pot
      $22.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 2pc Makeup gift w/ $50 Tarte purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (3)
    • 4 colors
      Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Eye Shadow Stick
      $30.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free makeup gift with $50 Bobbi Brown purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (349)
    • Urban Decay Naked Petite Heat Eyeshadow Palette
      $29.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      FREE 3pc makeup gift w/ $50 Urban Decay purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (48)
    • 3 colors
      Shiseido Shimmering Cream Eye Color, 0.21 oz.
      $25.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (20)
    • Tarte Chrome Paint Shadow Pot in Park Ave Princess
      $22.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 2pc Makeup gift w/ $50 Tarte purchase
      Free gift with purchase
    • 2 colors
      Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick - Nude Beach Collection
      $30.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free makeup gift with $50 Bobbi Brown purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (62)
    • 11 colors
      MAC Extra Dimension Eye Shadow
      $20.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (60)
    • 5 colors
      MAC Pro Expansions Cream Colour Base
      $24.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $20.00 w/ Any Foundation Purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (9)
    • 6 colors
      Origins Ginzing Brightening Cream Shadow
      $21.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (123)
    • 11 colors
      Tarte Amazonian Clay Waterproof Eye Liner
      $21.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 2pc Makeup gift w/ $50 Tarte purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (20)
    • Bobbi Brown 5-Pc. 90 Second Soft & Smokey Eyes Set
      A $118.00 value
      Only $65.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free makeup gift with $50 Bobbi Brown purchase
      Free gift with purchase
    • 3 colors
      Shiseido Shimmering Cream Eye Color, 0.21 oz.
      $25.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (6)
    • 9 colors
      NUDESTIX Magnetic Luminous Eye Color Pencil
      $24.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (8)
    • 7 colors
      NEW! bareMinerals Gen Nude® Cream Eyeshadow + Primer
      $20.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free gift with purchase
      Free 2pc Makeup gift w/ $35 bareMinerals purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      (8)
    • 3 colors
      Dior Diorshow Cooling Stick Cooling Effect Eyeshadow
      $25.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (1)
    • 8 colors
      NUDESTIX Magnetic Matte Eye Color
      $24.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (12)
    • 2 colors
      Smashbox + Vlada Petal Metal Shimmer Drops
      $32.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (1)
    • 4 colors
      Shiseido Paperlight Cream Eye Color, 0.21 oz.
      $25.00
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Bonus offer with purchase
      Makeup Gift - $26 w/ Any Eye Shadow purchase
      Bonus offer with purchase
      (2)
    • 4 colors