Current selected color: Buttercream
9 Colors
This shade is your best match.

Here's how it works:

  1. Receive 5% off your second order and all future shipments. Free shipping on orders over $20.
  2. Manage frequency, delivery, and quantity online.
  3. Email reminder sent before each delivery.
  4. Cancel easily at any time.
Learn More
  • 3
  • 8
  • 4
  • 3
  • 11
  • 8
In stock: Usually ships within 3 business days.

This dramatic eyeshadow delivers intense, pure, long-lasting matte color in a single stroke. Offering excellent adherence, the potent formulation is extremely comfortable on the eyelids and provides a smooth finish with a soft, creamy feel. The non-dusting color offers superior payoff and is easily layered or sheered while staying completely crease-resistant.

  • An eyeshadow that defines the eyes with a single stroke of pure, intense matte color.
  • Lightweight texture. Matte Finish. Longwearing.
  • Dry use only.
  • To accentuate or heighten the color of the eyes, choose shades that offer a contrast so the eye color will stand out.
  • To take your look from day to night, add a deeper, more intense color and liner.
  • Pop out your favorite shade from its compact and place it in a Custom Compact for a customized color eyeshadow palette.
  • All custom compacts sold separately.
  • Create classic eyes: use a lighter tone on the eyelid and under the brow bone, and add depth by accentuating the crease with a dark or medium shade. Smudge the deepest shade at the lash line.

Web ID: 351707

Customer reviews

92 Reviews
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Star
User Images
    Macygal 23
    May 26, 2024
    from LI NY
    Smooth powder

    Nice base color , more matte base colors

    May 20, 2024
    from Wenatchee, Wa
    I love this eyeshadow. Matte and goes on perfectly

    Best eyeshadow

    Apr 29, 2024
    from buffalo
    Nice quality eyeshadow

    This is a very good quality eyeshadow.Even though it is a matte it is very silky and applies very smooth .It stays on well too..The brown shade was nice ,rich but not too dark.

    Mar 31, 2024
    Love LM shadows

    [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Beautiful everyday base color. Stays Perfect all day.

    Customer review from
    Mar 25, 2024
    from Jersey City, NJ
    Found what I needed after much searching at Macy’s

    Laura Mercer discontinued this amazing cake eye liner that I have used for years. I tried other brands but they were awful. I kept searching online to see if anyone still carried it and lo and behold…. Macy’s did!!! It was easy to order - I ordered two and am thinking of ordering more to keep me going for years. Macy’s online ordering was super easy and I am so happy that they kept a stash somewhere in their array of stores.

    Mar 10, 2024
    from Hilton Head, SC
    Hard to find mattes!

    Nice matte shade. Get for older skin where shimmer doesn’t work

    Stephanie I
    Mar 01, 2024
    Natural Neutral Eye Colour Shade

    [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have been wearing Laura Mercier Matte Eye Colour for many years and have various shades. This Cafe Au Lait is a neutral, natural shade that looks great, whether applied very light for daytime or heavier for evenings. There is a tiny glint of shimmer.

    Customer review from
    Dec 24, 2023
    ❤️ this eyeshadow

    Love this eye shadow I was so happy to find it at Bluemercury❤️

    Customer review from