Current selected color: Buttercream
9 Colors
This shade is your best match.

Here's how it works:

  1. Receive 5% off your second order and all future shipments. Free shipping on orders over $20.
  2. Manage frequency, delivery, and quantity online.
  3. Email reminder sent before each delivery.
  4. Cancel easily at any time.
Learn More
  • 3
  • 8
  • 4
  • 3
  • 11
  • 8
In stock: Usually ships within 3 business days.

This dramatic eyeshadow delivers intense, pure, long-lasting matte color in a single stroke. Offering excellent adherence, the potent formulation is extremely comfortable on the eyelids and provides a smooth finish with a soft, creamy feel. The non-dusting color offers superior payoff and is easily layered or sheered while staying completely crease-resistant.

  • WHAT IT DOES:
  • An eyeshadow that defines the eyes with a single stroke of pure, intense matte color.
  • Lightweight texture. Matte Finish. Longwearing.
  • HOW TO USE:
  • Dry use only.
  • To accentuate or heighten the color of the eyes, choose shades that offer a contrast so the eye color will stand out.
  • To take your look from day to night, add a deeper, more intense color and liner.
  • Pop out your favorite shade from its compact and place it in a Custom Compact for a customized color eyeshadow palette.
  • All custom compacts sold separately.
  • Create classic eyes: use a lighter tone on the eyelid and under the brow bone, and add depth by accentuating the crease with a dark or medium shade. Smudge the deepest shade at the lash line.

Web ID: 351707

Customer reviews

92 Reviews
5 Stars
77
4 Stars
6
3 Stars
6
2 Stars
2
1 Star
1
User Images
    Macygal 23
    May 26, 2024
    from LI NY
    Smooth powder

    Nice base color , more matte base colors

    Judi
    May 20, 2024
    from Wenatchee, Wa
    I love this eyeshadow. Matte and goes on perfectly

    Best eyeshadow

    Gma
    Apr 29, 2024
    from buffalo
    Nice quality eyeshadow

    This is a very good quality eyeshadow.Even though it is a matte it is very silky and applies very smooth .It stays on well too..The brown shade was nice ,rich but not too dark.

    LoveXOXO
    Mar 31, 2024
    Love LM shadows

    [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Beautiful everyday base color. Stays Perfect all day.

    Customer review from bloomingdales.com
    Harriet
    Mar 25, 2024
    from Jersey City, NJ
    Found what I needed after much searching at Macy’s

    Laura Mercer discontinued this amazing cake eye liner that I have used for years. I tried other brands but they were awful. I kept searching online to see if anyone still carried it and lo and behold…. Macy’s did!!! It was easy to order - I ordered two and am thinking of ordering more to keep me going for years. Macy’s online ordering was super easy and I am so happy that they kept a stash somewhere in their array of stores.

    scunasiren
    Mar 10, 2024
    from Hilton Head, SC
    Hard to find mattes!

    Nice matte shade. Get for older skin where shimmer doesn’t work

    Stephanie I
    Mar 01, 2024
    Natural Neutral Eye Colour Shade

    [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have been wearing Laura Mercier Matte Eye Colour for many years and have various shades. This Cafe Au Lait is a neutral, natural shade that looks great, whether applied very light for daytime or heavier for evenings. There is a tiny glint of shimmer.

    Customer review from bloomingdales.com
    Toni1113
    Dec 24, 2023
    ❤️ this eyeshadow

    Love this eye shadow I was so happy to find it at Bluemercury❤️

    Customer review from bluemercury.com