First Test Graphic Novel: A Graphic Novel by Tamora Pierce
Product details
Web ID: 18496880Well done graphic novel but not quite stand alone
This was a well done graphic novel. I have never read any of the books in the series, so I will admit that I am coming at this from the perspective of someone who doesn't understand the world and so was a little lost at the start because the graphic novel seems to assume you know the world in which it is set well enough to understand all of the roles and people. Once I got past the first few pages, I did find it a lot easier to get into the story and the characters. Keladry is likeable and she figures out a way to fit in without truly fitting in. I did rail against the men who thought that because she was, well, a girl, she could not join the boys in training and fighting. There are definitely challenges that come with being a woman in physical combat, but deciding something is beyond her ability should be her decision and not that of her peers, especially when some of the things would be beyond their abilities either. The depiction of hazing and the pressure to not speak out is very much relevant to what goes on for people in our time and world, and I feel like it's handled well, albeit in a way that would probably reinforce not talking to adults about bullying. But other than that, the book does a good job of telling an engaging story. I did want to see more of her relationship with her horse which, as a horse lover, is expected. Also felt like we spent time with the selection of her mount and the mage who can speak to animals but then it kind of fizzles. Artwork is nice. Some panels were a bit dark, but I was also reading on a phone. If you are fan of Pierce and her books, especially this series, I'm pretty sure this would appeal. And if you have never read them, then this would likely be a good way into the series. Also a good option for a reader who likes fantasy but doesn't really like novels.
Recommends this product
Customer review from barnesandnoble.com
Fantastic graphic novel of a beloved series
I am a huge Tamora Pierce fan and especially love Kel! I was so excited to see that her story was being turned into a graphic novel. While of course some parts of the book don’t make it in, I think the most important parts of Kel’s story were kept. I really love how Kel’s first adventure is portrayed. Beloved lines of dialogue will be recognizable to readers who have read the original book. The art was beautiful and designed with care. I hope that this book brings even more readers into the Tamora Pierce world and creates even more accessibility. I loved First Test and would highly recommend it to anyone! Readers who enjoy strong characters determined to fight for what’s right, lovable characters, and adventure need to read this graphic novel. I can’t wait to see the story continue!
Recommends this product
Customer review from barnesandnoble.com