[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Absolutely love this Bobbi Brown mascara! It works great at making my lashes look dark, full and curled. Best of all, it is the first mascara to not cause an allergic reaction to my eyes. I highly recommend this product!

Mascara was old and completely dried up. Expensive and a waste of money.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Great mascara

I have been using the Smokey Eye Mascara since it was introduced. I have always loved it. I thought it lengthened and thickened my eye lashes and was the best I had ever used. Over the last year or year and a half, I noticed the mascara was drying out more quickly than before-within just a couple of weeks and it would leave pieces of black under my eyes and on my cheeks when I was applying because it was so dry. In addition, I noticed that it was smudging more than it had in the past. I'm not sure if you've changed the formula and are putting less mascara in the tube, but I'm very disappointed in what I thought was a superior product in the marketplace.

I have used this for years. I am 66. It is great! Not gloppy, not messy, good lash definition. Highly recommend.

This mascara goes on like a dream but by the end of the day it is smudging under my eyes. Makes me sad because it looks so good when you first put it on.

Wow! Wow! Best mascara sold in just black. This product is amazing it comes off well with any make up remover. No smudge it’s the best product for lashes

This does not compare to the other Bobbi Brown mascara that I have purchased in the past. I will not be buying this particular mascara again. it’s as if I have nothing on my eyelashes