[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I really like how it goes on. Creamy but doesn’t smear!

Really nice formal, easy to apply with no tugging. Lasts about 8-9 hours and is easy to remove with facial cleanser. The pencil sharpens easily and helps create a thin straight line. I have a hard time getting my eyeliner to be “even” because my eyes aren’t even, but this pencil makes it much easier. Three cheers for this super eyeliner!

I don’t really like it. The led is not stable in the pencil and it doesn’t go on as smooth as I had hoped

I love that you can actually sharpen the pencil. Other “pencils” have a stick of color inside a plastic tube that breaks off easily and has a greasy consistency. This pencil does not. It is a solid pencil that you are able sharpen as you use. Mine has lasted over 6 months. PLEASE do not discontinue the product.

The reason for 3 stars - the tip of the pencil broke off on second use. Just hope the whole pencil doesn’t do this. Don’t know if there should have been more padding around it for mailing protection or what.

I am a person who values quality. I have been a long time user of the Laura Mercier Black/Violet eye pencil. Unfortunately, the product was discontinued. Now, in its place are the Longwewr Creme Eye Pencils. Sadly, this product does not even paint. You glide back and forth and hardly anything is there just a faint line. I wish the Black/Violet eye pencil was never discontinued. Now I am on the hunt for an eye pencil that actually paints.

I didn’t like it as much as I thought because it doesn’t go on evenly or easily.

Have used this product for years. Pleased with the Color and the smoothness of putting it on.