I've been using this for YEARS! It's amazing. I use it to clean up my liquid eyeliner cat eyes lines and it's the only product that won't run or smudge the make up. It is also gentle and takes off even the most stubborn makeup. Just hold the cotton round on for 3 or so seconds and then wipe. Also, after about a decade of using this, the area around my eyes is still wrinkle free and firm. Maybe it's the remover... maybe genetics? Either way, this is a staple in my routine.

I love this product Works better than most and is not oily

This might be fine for gentle cleansing or to clean off eye shadow, but it wasn't at all effective for me. I use primer on my eyes, eye shadow, waterproof eye liner, and use false lashes. This product was not in the least effective for any of it, had to resort to using other brands.

I have sensitive skin and this is the only eye make up remover I can use. It has good ingredients without harsh chemicals and doesn't irritate my skin because it's so gentle. I've been using this for more than 20 years and still counting! I highly recommend this to anybody who has sensitive skin.

This product hurts my skin, does not remove well mascara and leaves a detergent film on my skin. The clean energy product was 1000x better. Not sure why it was discontinued. Please escalate this request to management. As many others if you'd. We'd like the Clean Energy oil based makeup remover BACK!!! Best makeup remover EVER!!!

This eye makeup remover is gentle and thorough. No need to rub hard and risk damaging the skin. It is pricey but worth it.

This doesn't remove mascara. What happened to the cleansing oil? It was amazing and took everything off without rubbing hard and left no trace of any makeup. Why discontinue something we all loved???? I used to buy 6 at a time so I didn't run out of it.

Requires a lot of rubbing to get off Origins own mascara and it stings if you get it in your eyes.