If i could give it zero stars I would. Ive been using the medium stay all day pen for years but then they replaced it with new colors which are warm rather then cool browns, so i tried this one as the color seemed the same as the original medium, but it has a strange greenish tint to it compared to before. I want my original back it was THE best!!!

LOVE this waterproof eyebrow pen! I use the Medium and the color matches my brows perfectly. Other pens are way too dark for my eyebrow color and they go on way too thick. I have had some pens last longer than the others, maybe they are old, but I will continue to buy this eyebrow pen.

This color and wear on this product is better than anything on the market for those of us with little or no brow hair. Works for chemo, alopecia, or people who just overplucked. However, the balayage end isn't as good as just having a pen. I've been disappointed enough to try several competitor products for a pen-only replacement. I've found pens that don't dry out as fast as Stila's, but the product wear and colors are inferior. The Stila pen was truly the best - please bring it back.

This was dried out right out of the box. Unable to use it. I want the old pen back.

Wow super surprised about all the bad ratings, I used the light color only and I LOVE it. My brows, which have thinned with age, look natural and I can apply quickly. I just tried to buy another and I'm sad the light is sold out :(

I've used the medium color for years and years until they changed the pen to this style. It's awful! Right out of the box it feels dried out. I prefer just the one side with a simple tip. No need for the 3 pronged side. Does the same thing and the single tip is more precise. Just please bring back the other pen. It worked much better! Please! The medium color is perfect and so is the formula just not this style pen.

Extremely disappointed that Stila discontinued the Waterproof bow liner w/out the balayage. Colors were fantastic, nothing else on the market like it. Now you have to buy this combo and they do not have light brown as they did in the past, only medium. Not everyone is medium complexion. Very disappointed

Nothing else compares, it looks natural, doesn't pull red and not super dark like some pens, love it but either there's not enough product in the pen or it dries rather fast, so each pen only lasts like 2 months tops with daily use. The color is perfection tho, so here I am stocking up