These curtains are GORGEOUS! High quality, thick fabric, beautiful design, perfectly symmetrical, lovely buttons! One panel of the two that arrived in the set have indented circles all over it and the circles are brown. This is so disheartening as these were for a time-sensitive gift on a puppet theatre we'd built for our kids. I cannot get through to anyone at Macy's, these are not in store and it's impossible to exchange online. I'm either going to have to attempt to remove the stains on the defective fabric myself or continue to attempt to reach the store. I had such high hopes for these. If you are thinking about purchasing, go for it! I honestly think I just received a defective set of panels.