The top I received went well below my knees and was long sleeve as you can see in the picture. Macy's clothing have really gone downhill. Sizing is very inconsistent, and very low quality. Definitely not the same top.

Been a Macy's customer over sixty years. The fabric on this shirt is flimsy and shows the bumps and rolls if you know what I mean. The workmanship is terrible and not worthy of Macy's selling it.

Material to clingy

Has a bad smell but fits well. Washing to see if it goes away. Weird

Great fit and very flattering stle. Looks great with leggings and boots.

I am 5'4 and this fits like a dress, rather than a tunic top. I might try a smaller size. It's made in the USA, which is super great!!!