I love the way this glides onto the bottom part of my eyes and think the black looks classy and clean. HOWEVER, if you wear contacts BEWARE. I've tried everything: lining the inner part of my eye, lining the outer part of my eye, pressing gently, one stroke, thin line, thick line. I swear no matter what it ALWAYS smudges onto my contacts and I end up having to throw them away because my contact solution can't get it off. I must have lost $150 worth contacts. If I ever use it again it will only be on my upper lid.