Cruelty Free Eye Makeup

(139)

Anastasia Beverly Hills
Mini Volumizing Tinted Brow Gel, 0.07 oz.
Current price $16.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(36)
Grande Cosmetics
GrandeDRAMA Intense Thickening Mascara
Current price $25.00; ;
Women Founded
(327)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
2-Pc. Laminated Brow Essentials Set
Current price $19.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(890)
Tarte
Travel-Size Tartelette XL Tubing Mascara
Current price $15.00; ;
Women Founded
(99)
Too Faced
Disco Crush High-Shine Glitter Eye & Face Sparkle
Current price $30.00; ;
LGBTQ Founded
(5)
bareMinerals
Mineralist Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner
Current price $22.00; ;
free gift with purchase
Women Founded
(396)
Chella
La Vie Neutral Eyeshadow Palette Travel Size
Current price $22.00; ;
(1)
IT Cosmetics
Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing and Lengthening Mascara
Current price $28.00; ;
Women Founded
(2,511)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Mini Brow Wiz
Current price $16.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(17)
Wander Beauty
Unlashed Volume & Curl Mascara
Current price $26.00; ;
(6)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Primrose Palette
Current price $55.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(517)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Glow Essentials
Current price From $22.00 to $42.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(12,733)
Smashbox
Full Exposure Lash Volumizing Mascara
Current price $28.00; ;
(290)
PÜR
Fully Charged Mascara
Current price $24.00; ;
(1,664)
Koh Gen Do
Eyebrow Pencil
Current price $65.00; ;
(30)
more colors available
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Five Steps to Perfect Brows
Current price From $22.00 to $26.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(14,510)
Tarte
Most Viral Products Collection
Current price From $27.00 to $32.00; ;
Women Founded
(3,640)
Urban Decay
Perversion Volumizing Mascara
Current price $28.00; ;
Women Founded
(437)
NUDESTIX
Magnetic Matte Eye Color
Current price $16.20; 40% off;
Previous price $27.00
(43)
Tarte
Big Ego Mascara
Current price $28.00; ;
Women Founded
(633)
Koh Gen Do
Universal Eyebrow Powder
Current price $70.00; ;
(26)
Tarte
Big Ego Mascara, Travel Size
Current price $15.00; ;
Women Founded
(96)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Lash Brag Volumizing Mascara
Current price From $16.00 to $25.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(795)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Mini Brow Freeze, 0.08 oz.
Current price $16.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(8)
Too Faced
Killer Liner 36-Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner, 0.04 oz.
Current price $26.00; ;
LGBTQ Founded
(171)
Natasha Moor
Eyes Bundle MesmerEYES Mini Colored Eyeliner Pencils Set, 4 Piece, 0.04 oz.
Current price $41.00; ;
Women Founded
(2)
Grande Cosmetics
GrandeBROW-FILL Volumizing Brow Gel
Current price $20.00; ;
Women Founded
(310)
The Crème Shop
3D Lashes
Current price $10.00; ;
(6)
Wander Beauty
Double Date Eyeshadow Duo
Current price $26.00; ;
(6)
Well People
Fresh Lines Eye Pencil
Current price $18.00; ;
LGBTQ Founded
(3)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Mini Brow Freeze Gel, 0.15 oz.
Current price $16.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(20)
NYX Professional Makeup
Zero To Brow Gel
Current price $13.00; ;
(541)
Koh Gen Do
Long Lush Treatment Mascara
Current price $71.00; ;
(52)
Tarte
Big Ego Sketch & Set Brow Pencil & Tinted Gel
Current price $26.00; ;
Women Founded
(458)
Smashbox
Always On Liquid Waterproof Eye Liner
Current price $25.00; ;
(345)
Smashbox
Always On Gel Eye Liner
Current price $25.00; ;
(374)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
NEW! Lash Sculpt Lengthening & Volumizing Deluxe-Size Mascara
Current price From $16.00 to $26.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(1,652)
Winky Lux
Uni-Brow Eyebrow Pencil
Current price $18.00; ;
(11)
Grande Cosmetics
GrandePRIMER Pre-Mascara Lengthener & Thickener
Current price $25.00; ;
Women Founded
(222)
PÜR
Big Look Mascara
Current price $24.00; ;
(114)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Anastasia’s Brow Must-Haves
Current price From $16.00 to $27.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(12,711)
bareMinerals
Maximist Phyto-Fiber Volumizing Mascara Mini
Current price $13.00; ;
free gift with purchase
Women Founded
(64)
Well People
Expressionist Brow Pencil
Current price $15.00; ;
LGBTQ Founded
(2)
Too Faced
Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eye Shadow Primer
Current price $28.00; ;
LGBTQ Founded
(392)
Well People
Expressionist Clear Brow Gel
Current price $14.00; ;
LGBTQ Founded
(1)
Wander Beauty
Wandering Eyes Shadow Stick
Current price $30.00; ;
FOREO
IRIS Eyelash Serum, 4.5 ml
Current price $59.90; ;
(3)
Doll 10
Luminous Undereye Corrector
Current price $30.00; ;
(3)
NYX Professional Makeup
Holiday Candy Swirl Liner, 0.03 oz.
Current price $10.00; ;
(1)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Lash Genius Serum Mini, 0.07 oz.
Current price $24.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(4)
Anastasia Beverly Hills
Lash Genius Serum, 0.12 oz.
Current price $48.00; ;
free gift with purchase
(5)
Well People
Fresh Lines Liquid Eyeliner
Current price $18.00; ;
LGBTQ Founded
(3)
Well People
Expressionist Brow Gel
Current price $18.00; ;
LGBTQ Founded
(3)
NYX Professional Makeup
Fill & Fluff Eyebrow Pomade Pencil
Current price $14.00; ;
(1,145)
Tarte
Big Ego Sketch & Set Brow Pencil & Tinted Gel, Travel Size
Current price $15.00; ;
Women Founded
(458)
Winky Lux
So Extra Mascara, 0.27 oz.
Current price $19.00; ;
(1)
Urban Decay
Brow Beater
Current price $24.00; ;
Women Founded
(86)
Wander Beauty
Mile High Club Length & Define Mascara
Current price $26.00; ;
NYX Professional Makeup
Micro Brow Pencil
Current price $12.00; ;
(1,962)
Tarte
Tarteist PRO Lash Collection
Current price $15.00; ;
Women Founded
(233)

1
2
3

Shop by category

Mascara Eyeshadow Eyeliner Eyebrow Makeup Eyelash Serum & Primers Eye Primer False Eyelashes