Free Shipping with $49 purchase + Free Store Pickup. Contiguous US. Exclusions
Macy's Presents: The Edit- A curated mix of fashion and inspiration Check It Out
ADS FROM UNAFFILIATED SITES

Best Eyeliner Pencil

Upgrade a beauty routine by using the best eyeliner pencil. A day look can be easily updated to a night look with a couple of swipes of a luxurious eyeliner. Whether looking for a dark, dramatic look or a soft, whimsical shade there is a large assortment of colors and textures from which to choose.

Add some sparkle and shine with the help of a MAC Archie's Girls eyeliner. Enjoy the look of an intense smudge-proof eyeliner that lasts all day. Simply apply the rich, luxurious smudge-proof eyeliner and then add a choice of eye shadow and mascara to take this look over the top. Pick from soft pastels to rich colors to achieve a new look from day-to-day. Choose a pencil with an easy to use soft texture to last all day.

Step outside of the box of traditional eyeliner pencils and go for a Sue Devitt eye illuminator pencil. This highlighting eyeliner will emphasize the natural eye color leaving eyes looking brilliant and clear. Apply around the eye while using a special angled smudge-tip to reach the inner corner and upper brow bone for a flawless look. Pick a soft gold color for a soft, natural tone.

Speed up a makeup routine with some Clinique Quickliner. Enjoy the quickness of an automatic eyeliner and how easy it is to apply eyeliner. With a silky formula this automatic eyeliner glides around eyes with ease, offering a sleek, sophisticated appearance. Use the best eyeliner pencil alone or wear it with some favorite eyeshadow and mascara. Easy to apply, the eyeliner comes off quickly with some makeup remover.

Go for a professional look with some Lancome Artliner eyeliner. This liquid eyeliner is an easy choice for those who want their makeup looking like a professional had applied it. Featuring deep, luminous pigments the liquid eyeliner features dramatic color that surround eyes with ease leaving them looking dark and mysterious. Gliding on easily, the liquid eyeliner offers long-lasting color that will go easily from day-to-night without smudging.

Come find the best eyeliner pencil today at Macy's!

 

more
  • 176 items in Best Eyeliner Pencil

    • Filter
    • Sort By
    • All Items (176)
    • Free Pick Up
    • Sort by
    • 10 colors
      Estée Lauder Double Wear Infinite Waterproof Eyeliner
      $25.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (434)
    • 10 colors
      Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil
      $25.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (540)
    • 11 colors
      Clinique Quickliner for Eyes, .01 oz.
      $17.50
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (838)
    • Tarte Tarteist™ Double Take Eyeliner
      $24.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (28)
    • 19 colors
      Lancôme Le Stylo Waterproof Long Lasting Eye Liner
      $27.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (696)
    • 10 colors
      Clinique Quickliner for Eyes Intense, 0.012 oz
      $17.50
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (528)
    • 12 colors
    • 36 colors
      Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
      $20.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (6220)
    • 9 colors
      MAC Technakohl Eye Liner
      $18.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (184)
    • Clinique 6-Pc. Spring Into Color Gift Set
      A $81.50 value
      Only $39.50
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (18)
    • 6 colors
      Lancôme Artliner Liquid Eyeliner
      $30.50
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (133)
    • 7 colors
      Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
      $22.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (139)
    • Lancôme Artliner Precision Point EyeLiner
      $30.50
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (455)
    • 6 colors
      Lancôme Le Crayon Khol Smoky Eye Liner
      $26.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (332)
    • 14 colors
      INGLOT AMC Eyeliner Gel, 0.19 oz
      $16.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (180)
    • 2 colors
      Clinique Pretty Easy Liquid Eyelining Pen, 0.07 oz
      $21.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (214)
    • 10 colors
      Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner, 0.1 oz
      $27.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (2416)
    • Clinique 3-Pc. Treats To Go Set - Punch
      A $34.00 value
      Only $18.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (1)
    • 8 colors
      MAC Pro Longwear Eye Liner
      $21.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (164)
    • 6 colors
      MAC Eye Kohl
      $18.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (109)
    • Estée Lauder 3-Pc. Bronze Beauty Sunlit Nudes Eye Set
      A $52.00 value
      Only $32.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (1)
    • 2 colors
      Estée Lauder Double Wear Zero Smudge Liquid Eyeliner
      $26.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (210)
    • 7 colors
      MAC Liquidlast Eye Liner
      $21.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (184)
    • 4 colors
      MAC Fluidline Gel Eye Liner
      $18.00 - 18.50
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (274)
    • Estée Lauder Little Black Liner
      $32.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (97)
    • 5 colors
      Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil
      $20.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (5480)
    • 18 colors
      Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Colour, 0.05 oz
      $29.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (375)
    • 2 colors
      Shiseido Automatic Fine Eyeliner, 0.04 fl. oz.
      $29.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (12)
    • Clinique 3-Pc. Treats To Go Set - Cherry
      A $37.00 value
      Only $18.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (3)
    • 2 colors
      MAC Brushstroke Eye Liner
      $21.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (46)
    • Estée Lauder 3-Pc. Golden Eyes Gift Set
      A $52.00 value
      Only $32.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (10)
    • 7 colors
      Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Gel Eyeliner
      $27.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (192)
    • 4 colors
      Lancôme Grandiose Liner
      $32.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (129)
    • Estée Lauder 3-Pc. Romantic Beauty Extreme Smoky Eye Set
      A $52.00 value
      Only $32.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (4)
    • 6 colors
      Shiseido Inkstroke Eyeliner, 0.15 oz.
      $30.00
      Free gift with purchase
      Free Selfie Light with any $45 cosmetics purchase
      Free gift with purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      Free Shipping & Returns with any Beauty Purchase
      Free shipping & returns
      (5)
    • 2 colors